Article Text

PDF

“Tomber dans les pommes” – can head injury cause brain damage?
  1. P McCrory

    Statistics from Altmetric.com

    Those readers looking for some amusing leisure time reading need look no further than the December issue of the Canadian Medical Association Journal. The enterprising authors—Antoine Cyr (age 5 years) and his brother Louise-Oliver (age 7 years) in conjunction with their father—analysed the adventures of Tintin in an attempt to discover why the Tintin grew no taller from 1929 to 1975, never had a girlfriend, and never needed to shave.1

    After an exhaustive review of the published literature, episodes of head injury were identified by the authors and the injury severity determined by the duration of loss of consciousness (as measured by the number of frames before Tintin returned to normal activity) and the number of stars revolving above Tintin’s head following injury.

    Rather surprisingly a total of 50 episodes of head injury were identified (43 were AAN grade 3 concussion injuries) in Tintin’s career. The mean length of LOC was 7.5 frames. The number of concussive events per adventure ranged from two to six, and most were blunt object impacts. Despite the absence of formal neuroimaging or neuro-endocrine assessment, the authors postulated that the repeated head trauma resulted in hypogonadotrophic hypogonadism and growth hormone deficiency, which in turn would explain his delayed statural growth, delayed onset of puberty, and lack of libido.

    This is the first report of such a syndrome occurring following concussion. Pituitary and hypothalamic dysfunction is seen not uncommonly following severe head trauma or in the setting of raised intracranial pressure after head injury but to date such a phenomenon has not been reported with concussive injury. As a result one would have to speculate that Tintin was in fact suffering from primary hypothalamic dysfunction and his clumsiness and repeated head trauma was incidental. The occurrence of repeated concussive injuries in athletes has been documented previously and thought to reflect the individuals risk taking behaviour rather than an intrinsic potential for injury2. In Tintin’s case, annual neuropsychological screening may be advisable to detect and hopefully prevent any long term cognitive deterioration.

    It has been suggested by some authors3,4 that repeated concussive injuries may be a risk factor for “second impact syndrome”; however, this has been questioned due to the limited evidence for its existence.5 In Tintin’s case, fear of this putative complication seems to have not been a management concern in his return to normal activity.

    Some anecdotal return to play guidelines6,7 would recommend immediate retirement or termination of the current adventure given that Tintin often experiences more than three concussive episodes in a short space of time. However, the Vienna guidelines8 recommend no mandatory exclusion period but individualised assessment of recovery—a strategy that Tintin appears to have followed in preference. If these guidelines were strictly adhered to, however, then he would have to terminate the adventure following the initial injury and Snowy the dog or Captain Haddock may have to play a more central role in the story outcome.

    I can only suggest that Tintin play close attention to the forthcoming Prague guidelines in view of his propensity of concussive injury in order to avoid long term problems.

    REFERENCES

    View Abstract

    Request permissions

    If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.