Article Text

PDF

Benefits of exercise therapy for chronic diseases
  1. U M Kujala
  1. Correspondence to:
 Dr Kujala
 Department of Health Sciences, University of Jyvaskyla, PO Box 35, Jyvaskyla, Finland; urho.kujala{at}sport.jyu.fi

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Evidence on the benefits of exercise therapy for chronic diseases based on randomised controlled trials is accumulating

Regular physical activity is one means of decreasing disability and increasing the number of independently living elderly people, as well as decreasing the costs of the healthcare system. On the basis of a recent review of the results of randomised controlled trials (RCTs), there is accumulating evidence that, in patients with chronic disease, exercise therapy is effective in increasing fitness and correcting some risk factors for the development of disease complications.1

FROM PREVENTION TO TREATMENT

Traditionally physical activity has been regarded as a powerful tool in the prevention of certain chronic diseases, even though this has been confirmed in only a very few cases by RCTs.2 When the strength of evidence for the use of exercise in health care is evaluated, data from epidemiological observational follow ups, studies on the mechanisms of disease, and controlled clinical trials are used. Observational follow up studies can be biased for many reasons, such as genetic selection bias and inability to control for all confounding lifestyle factors.3 However, it has been widely accepted that an epidemiological observational study with supportive data from studies on disease mechanisms provides enough evidence for exercise recommendations in disease prevention. Conclusive evidence for the benefits of exercise in the treatment of patients with chronic disease using the limited resources of the healthcare system should optimally be based on well designed RCTs.1 Recently, the number of RCTs evaluating the effects of physical exercise therapy for specific diseases has increased substantially, allowing disease specific systematic reviews including meta-analyses.

MAIN FINDINGS OF SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS BASED ON RCTS

The most consistent finding of the studies is that exercise capacity or muscle strength can be improved in patients with different diseases without having detrimental effects on disease progression.1 Severe complications in the exercise trials were rare. In some diseases, such as osteoarthritis, pain symptoms may also be reduced. Most RCTs are too short to document disease progression. Studies on patients with coronary heart disease,4 as well as studies on patients with heart failure,5 show that exercise groups have a somewhat reduced all-cause mortality. The clinically very significant findings include that exercise therapy has beneficial effects on all metabolic syndrome components and is highly beneficial for patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus.1,6

STUDY QUALITY IS IMPORTANT

Before the results are considered, the methodological quality of the individual RCTs should be critically analysed.7,8 Biased results from poorly designed and reported trials can mislead decision making. It should be taken into account that exercise trials cannot usually be properly blinded, which may lessen the reliability of the results. In addition to other quality criteria, we have to keep in mind that generalisability may be a problem as some RCTs include patients that are not representative of the general population of patients with regard to age and coexisting diseases. This is typically seen in RCTs on coronary heart disease and heart failure.

The fact that most trials are of short duration means that some benefits, such as increases in physical fitness, are reached within weeks or months. However, specific RCTs are usually too short to provide conclusive evidence on the effects of exercise therapy on the true progression of disease. RCTs on the effects of exercise on lipid risk factors, blood pressure levels, and glucose homoeostasis,6 as well as sporadic long term follow ups of disease progression,4,5 support the conclusion that exercise therapy may have a beneficial effect on the long term progression of specific diseases.1 However, there is a need for RCTs with long term follow ups, including documentation, of such outcomes as survival rate, rate of hospital admission, and healthcare costs.

CLINICAL PRESCRIPTION OF EXERCISE

Doctors prescribing exercise therapy have to know the basics of exercise physiology and training principles. Also, tailoring of a programme depends on the disease and its stage, the baseline fitness level of the patient, and the goals of the programme set together with the patient.

The available RCTs include a large variety of effective training programmes. Most patients seem to benefit from low to moderate intensity aerobic exercise. Detailed conclusions on the dose-response of exercise therapy in the treatment of specific diseases cannot be drawn from the available RCTs. We have to remember that the beneficial results of exercise therapies for patients with chronic disease shown by RCTs are based on carefully planned and followed exercise interventions in patients whose clinical status has first been examined to take into account possible risks. Unlike the prevention of disease in young healthy people, the therapeutic range of physical activity for patients with chronic disease may be limited. In exercise therapy, long term adherence is a general problem. Exercise consultations face to face or by telephone can be used to maintain high physical activity levels.9 Also, whereas we look for evidence of the benefits of exercise therapy from RCTs specifically investigating the effects of exercise, in clinical work we have to bear in mind that correction of other modifiable risk factors such as diet10 and smoking3 are also important, as is the optimal medication.

Evidence on the benefits of exercise therapy for chronic diseases based on randomised controlled trials is accumulating

REFERENCES

View Abstract

Footnotes

  • Competing interests: none declared

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.