Objectives: To investigate the influence of regular Tai Chi (TC) practice and jogging on muscle strength and endurance in the lower extremities of older people.
Methods: Twenty one long term older TC practitioners were compared with 18 regular older joggers and 22 sedentary counterparts. Maximum concentric strength of knee flexors and extensors was tested at angular velocities of 30°/s and 120°/s. Ankle dorsiflexors and plantar flexors were tested at 30°/s and the dynamic endurance of the knee flexors and extensors was assessed at a speed of 180°/s.
Results: The differences in the muscle strength of the knee joint amongst the three experimental groups were significant at the higher velocity. The strengths of knee extensors and flexors in the control group were significantly lower than those in the jogging group and marginally lower than those in the TC group. For the ankle joint, the subjects in both the TC and jogging groups generated more torque in their ankle dorsiflexors. In addition, the muscle endurance of knee extensors was more pronounced in TC practitioners than in controls.
Conclusion: Regular older TC practitioners and joggers showed better scores than the sedentary controls on most muscle strength and endurance measures. However, the magnitude of the exercise effects on muscles might depend on the characteristics of different types of exercise.
- COP, centre of pressure
- EI, endurance index
- PT, peak torque
- TC, Tai Chi
- muscle strength
- older people
- Tai Chi
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Impaired motor performance in older people is often characterised by a slowing of movement, a decrease in muscle strength, and a loss of fine motor coordination. These changes can have an important effect on the degree of autonomy of the older person. For example, muscle strength has been positively related to walking speed and stair climbing ability and negatively related to the incidence of hip fractures.1,2
Regular exercise is an important way of slowing or reversing some of the deterioration in muscular function that occurs with ageing. However, different kinds of exercise have different effects on muscle function. Resistance training protocols have generally been recognised as the best way to enhance muscular strength in the elderly.3–5 However, as regards aerobic activities common in older people, such as walking, jogging, or swimming and balance activities such as soft gymnastics, the results of studies focussing on muscle strength have not been consistent.6,7 The discrepancies were caused by differences in methods of measurement and training intensity and frequency, but the characteristics of the different types of exercise also need to be considered.
Tai Chi (TC) is an ancient Chinese conditioning exercise whose non-vigorous and gentle movements are suitable for older people. Regular TC practice can produce beneficial effects on health, particularly as regards the maintenance of postural control in older people.8,9 TC is thought to help prevent falls in the elderly because its movements incorporate elements of postural muscle strengthening, balance, postural alignment, and concentration.10 TC is performed in a semi-squat posture that can place a large load on the muscles of the lower extremities. The movements demand guided motions of the hip, knee, and ankle joints in various directions, requiring concentric and eccentric contractions of the hip, knee, and ankle muscles. These movements are similar to resistance exercises such as lunges, knee bends, and squats, in terms of the degrees of hip and knee flexion and extension that are required.11 Indeed, several studies have reported the benefits of TC exercise on muscle strength. Jacobson et al11 found significant improvements in the isometric strength of knee extensors after a 12 week TC intervention. Lan et al12 reported that a 12 month TC programme was effective in enhancing the strength of the knee joints, with a 20.3% improvement for extensors and a 15.9% improvement for flexors. Recently, Wu et al13 reported that people who practise TC had greater isokinetic strength of the quadriceps and a lower displacement of the foot centre of pressure (COP). Moreover, the authors showed that there was a good correlation between the eccentric strength of the knee extensors and the COP displacement. They pointed out that the maintenance of the eccentric strength of the postural muscles through the long term practice of TC is beneficial for maintaining good postural control.
TC practice has been shown to be effective in improving muscle strength in older people, but further research is required. Firstly, decline in muscular strength, particularly in the ankle, has been associated with falls in the elderly.14,15 To date, assessments of TC exercise on muscle strength have only focused on knee extensors or flexors; little has been mentioned about the effects on the muscles of the ankle joint. Secondly, there is a lack of comparison with other common physical activities. Regularly scheduled physical activity definitely promotes muscle function, but the effects of exercise on muscle strength are not identical due to the different types, intensity, and duration of exercise. Hence, this study measured the isokinetic strength of the knee and ankle joints, and knee muscle endurance in long term TC practitioners, long term joggers, and their sedentary counterparts. Jogging is one of the most common forms of exercise in older people and was thus selected as a contrast to TC exercise. The purpose of this study was to more comprehensively understand the effect of TC exercise on muscle function in older people.
A total of 61 older people were recruited by means of a questionnaire with a complementary interview on their physical and sporting activities (exercise experience, average exercise frequency, and duration of each exercise session). The universal inclusion criteria for all groups were: (a) aged 60 years or over; (b) predominantly healthy and with no history of significant cardiovascular, pulmonary, metabolic, musculoskeletal, or neurological disease; (c) no use of specific medications known to impair balance or strength; and (d) independent living in the community with a normally active life style. TC practitioners came from three clubs where hundreds of people practise TC together everyday under qualified TC masters. Joggers were recruited from a large health centre for older people where active individuals participate in regular exercise programs. The subjects in the sedentary control group were recruited from a large housing estate.
The TC group was composed of 21 subjects with 4 or more years of TC experience. They regularly practised Yang style TC everyday for approximately 60 min, but were not involved in any other regular physical activity. The practice session consisted of warm up stretching exercise (about 8 min), a complete TC routine, and cool down exercise (about 7 min). The jogging group included 18 older people who had jogged for at least 1 h each day over the past 4 years or more (including approximately 15 min of warm up and cool down). The average distance jogged was 7.9 km and average jogging speed was 8.6 km/h. The joggers occasionally performed other physical activities (swimming and bicycling), but had no TC experience. The sedentary controls had undertaken no regular exercise for more than 5 years. An informed consent form was completed by each subject before participation. The study was approved by the local medical ethics committee. No significant differences were noted in age, body height, body weight, or gender ratio across the three groups (table 1).
Testing was divided into two sections. The first assessed the strength and endurance of knee extensors and flexors. Then, after 20 min relaxation, the strength of ankle dorsiflexors and plantar flexors was evaluated. All tests were performed on the dominant leg of each subject.
A sub-maximal warm up exercise (50–60 W) was performed on a bicycle ergometer (Monark, Varberg, Sweden) for 5 min before muscle tests. The Cybex Norm isokinetic dynamometer system (Cybex, Medway, MA, USA) was used to measure the torque and work produced by specific muscle groups.
Subjects sat on the examination chair with a hip angle of 90° and were stabilised with straps around the thigh, abdomen, and thorax. The axis of the tested knee was aligned with the rotation axis of the dynamometer, and the lower leg was attached to the lever arm of the dynamometer. Isokinetic strength was measured using preset angular velocities of 30°/s and 120°/s of concentric actions for knee flexors and extensors at the full available range of motion. Three maximal contractions were measured and the highest peak torque (PT) was reported. A 1.5 min rest period was allowed between the two sets of data collection at the different velocities. All torque data were normalised per kilogram of body weight for analyses (PT%).
After 3 min relaxation on the bicycle ergometer, the dynamic endurance of the knee extensors and flexors was assessed by recording 40 repeated maximum isokinetic contractions with an angular velocity of 180°/s. Subjects were instructed to push and pull “as hard and as fast as possible” in every single movement. The work expended by a knee angular motion of 10–80° was recorded. The endurance index (EI) was defined as the ratio of the work during the last five contractions over the first five contractions.
For measurement of isokinetic ankle dorsiflexion and plantarflexion, subjects were positioned lying supine, with the foot attached to a footplate and fixed with two belts. The ankle joint was aligned with the axis of the dynamometer. The isokinetic contractions were performed at an angular velocity of 30°/s. Before testing, each subject performed a warm up exercise of three submaximal repetitions to familiarise themselves with the equipment. For the isokinetic test, the subjects were instructed to push the foot away from them and pull it towards them at maximum velocity through the full available range of motion for each repetition. PT was determined as the highest torque generated from the three trials, and the PT% data were analysed.
All variables were presented as means and standard deviations. One way analysis of variance was used to determine significant differences amongst the groups. Post hoc Tukey tests were performed when necessary to isolate the differences and p⩽0.05 was considered to be statistically significant.
The mean concentric PT% of knee flexors and extensors at the velocity of 30°/s in TC and jogging subjects showed a clear trend for being greater than those in the control group, although the differences did not reach significant levels (p = 0.058 for knee flexors, p = 0.165 for knee extensors) (fig 1). The differences in muscle strength amongst the three groups were significant at the velocity of 120°/s (p = 0.001 for knee flexors, p = 0.003 for knee extensors). Post hoc comparisons indicated that the concentric strengths of knee extensors and flexors in the control group were significantly lower than those in the jogging group (p = 0.001 for flexors, p = 0.003 for extensors) and marginally lower than those in the TC group (p = 0.09 for flexors, p = 0.06 for extensors) (fig 2). No significant differences in knee muscle strength were found between the TC and jogging groups.
The PT% of dorsiflexors significantly differed amongst the three groups (p = 0.012), whereas that of plantarflexors did not (p = 0.077). Further comparisons showed that the subjects in both the TC (p = 0.029) and jogging (p = 0.027) groups generated more torque in their ankle dorsiflexors. No significant differences in the PT% of ankle dorsiflexors and plantar flexors were observed between the TC and jogging groups (fig 3).
All subjects were able to perform the 40 maximum isokinetic contractions at the velocity of 180°/s. As the EI is the ratio of the work during the last five contractions over the first five contractions, a larger index reflects a greater resistance to fatigue. For knee extensors, the TC subjects demonstrated a significantly greater EI than did the sedentary controls (p = 0.027), thus indicating a better ability to maintain a higher torque level throughout the 40 contractions. The mean value of EI in the jogging group was greater than that in the control group, and slightly lower than that in the TC group, but the differences were not significant. Similar data were noted for the knee flexors: the TC group displayed the best EI, the jogging group displayed the second best, and the control group showed the worst EI, although the differences between the groups were not significant (fig 4).
As predicted, long term regular exercisers scored or tended to score better than the sedentary controls on most of the muscle strength and endurance measures. However, the magnitude of the exercise effects on each muscle was different in the different types of exercise. The regular joggers were much stronger than the controls in the ankle dorsiflexors, and knee flexors and extensors at high contractile speed, whereas significant effects of TC exercise were only seen in the ankle dorsiflexors. However, the muscle endurance of knee extensors was more pronounced in the TC practitioners than in the controls.
There is little doubt that muscles weaken as an individual grows old, with dynamic strength being compromised to a greater extent than isometric strength.16,17 However, many studies have indicated that older people adapt to resistance and endurance exercise training in a similar fashion to young people, and the decline in the metabolic and force producing capacity of muscles can no longer be considered an inevitable consequence of the ageing process.18 Older people who have maintained a physically active lifestyle have demonstrated better muscle strength and endurance than their age matched less active peers. Laforest et al19 reported that elderly regular tennis players had greater knee muscle strength at both low and high contractile speeds, and better endurance of knee extensors, than their sedentary peers. Our data do not seem very consistent with these findings. However, it should be noted that almost all of these cross sectional studies carried out comparisons between active and inactive people. Few studies have considered the possible effects of different forms of exercise. When we individually compared the differences in muscle strength and endurance between the TC practitioners and the controls, and between the joggers and the controls, using an independent t test, the results agreed with those of similar studies. Almost all muscle strength parameters in the exercisers were significantly better than those in their sedentary counterparts, except for plantarflexor strength in the TC group and the endurance of knee flexors in the jogging group. Hence, we believe that our results might be a function of the characteristics of the specific forms of exercise. TC combines deep diaphragmatic breathing with slow, gentle movements, both isometric and isotonic. Participants step with full weight on both lower extremities in a semi-squatting posture, but the heel strike is more gentle than in walking because of slow and deliberate foot placement.20 Thus TC is regarded as a low impact and low velocity exercise.21 Comparatively, both TC and jogging use body weight as resistance, but jogging should produce more vigorous impact on the lower extremities than TC because of the type of exercise. Although it was difficult to accurately compare exercise intensity between TC practitioners and joggers using the present study design, the subjects in the two groups had similar exercise frequency, duration, and years of experience (both groups had exercised for approximately 1 h every day for at least 4 years). The level of physical activity involvement in both groups should be regarded as equal. Our results are similar to those of Gauchard et al7 who compared the muscular strength of elderly subjects who regularly practised proprioceptive (yoga and soft gymnastics) or bioenergetic (jogging, swimming, and cycling) physical activities, and controls. The bioenergetic group showed the best muscular strength and power in the ankle and knee joints, while the proprioceptive group had average values. The authors specially mentioned that the ritual motions of TC constituted proprioceptive exercise.
When comparing the four muscle groups of the lower extremities in the TC group with those in the controls, there were significantly greater gains only in the ankle dorsiflexors. This might be because most forms of TC particularly emphasise movements involving ankle dorsiflexion, such as slowly raising and lowering the toes under tension, dorsiflexed foot left or right turn, etc. TC exercises always give priority to improving the function of the specific muscle groups used in the exercise. Balance is influenced by strength in the muscles that control the ankle, knee, and hip, which are used in postural movements and gait.22 Conversely, loss of strength in the dorsiflexor muscles is associated with falls and with difficulty in performing certain activities of daily living.14,23 Whipple et al15 reported that at the higher, more functional limb velocities, ankle weakness, particularly that which involves the dorsiflexors, appears to be an important factor underlying poor balance. Obviously, the maintenance of dorsiflexor strength in the long term TC practitioners and joggers is likely to be beneficial for proper postural control.
Another interesting finding is that significant effects of jogging on knee muscle strength only showed at higher velocity. Rogers and Evans18 suggested that preferential loss and/or atrophy of fast twitch fibres (type II) is associated with ageing. Older people have fewer, but on average larger and slower, motor units.24 A relatively greater decrease in torque with increasing speeds was thus characteristic of knee extensors in older subjects.1,19,25 In the present study, it seems that jogging counteracts this impairment. This might be very important for older people, because high speed muscle contraction is necessary for them to maintain function in daily activities, such as walking at a normal speed and responding in a timely manner to disturbance.
Increased muscle endurance might be of great practical importance to older people as a means of reducing the increased risk of accidents and falling. Muscle endurance depends on the ability to transport oxygen to active muscles (cardiovascular factors) and the ability of muscles to use the oxygen supplied (intrinsic muscular biochemical factors).18,26 In our study, TC practitioners achieved the best scores on muscle endurance. TC movements are slow, continuous, smooth, and well controlled and TC has been regarded as a low intensity aerobic activity by some researchers.27 The characteristics of TC movement indicate that TC exercise involves the use of slow twitch muscle fibres which, when trained, have a greater concentration of myoglobin, more capillaries, and a higher content of mitochondria and thus mitochondrial enzymes, than fast twitch fibres. These factors mean slow twitch fibres have a high fatigue resistance due to their high capacity for aerobic metabolism. It is through this training response that regular TC exercise could improve muscle endurance.
What is already known on this topic
Regular exercise can slow or reverse some of the deterioration in muscular function that occurs with ageing. Tai Chi is an ancient Chinese conditioning exercise whose non-vigorous and gentle movements can help maintain postural control in older people
What this study adds
Both long term Tai Chi practice and long term jogging benefit muscle strength in the lower extremities. The maintenance of dorsiflexion strength and knee extension endurance in TC practitioners might be of practical importance for older people in everyday life.
In conclusion, our study confirmed that regular physical activity could produce positive effects on muscle function. Although the benefits of long term TC practice on muscle strength in the lower extremities did not seem superior to that of long term jogging, the maintenance of dorsiflexion strength and knee extension endurance in TC practitioners might be of practical importance for older people in everyday life.
The comparison between Tai Chi practitioners and joggers in this study is applauded since only a limited number of research papers have reported on the differences in the physical effects of Tai Chi exercise and other traditional exercises, such as jogging and running. The results of this study have demonstrated that Tai Chi exercise may have similar effects to running in terms of developing and maintaining the muscle strength and endurance of the lower extremities. In addition, Tai Chi is a body-mind harmony exercise in which the deep breathing matches the slow and graceful movements.
Competing interests: none declared
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.