Article Text

PDF
209
Concussion diagnosis: the king-devick test in the canadian football league
  1. Dhiren J Naidu1,2,
  2. Martin Mrazik1
  1. 1University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
  2. 2HealthPointe Medical Centres, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada

Abstract

Objective To conduct a sensitivity analysis of the King-Devick (K-D) test in professional football.

Design Prospective cohort.

Setting Professional football.

Participants: 269 professional football players from the Canadian Football League (CFL). There were 24 concussions to analyse.

Intervention The K-D test was added to the existing CFL concussion protocol (medical and SCAT3). All participants completed K-D assessments at baseline, at the time of injury/concussion (TOI), and at medical clearance prior to return to play (RTP). 20 controls were re-tested post-baseline.

Outcome measures K-D scores were analysed to construct a sensitivity analysis.

Main results TOI K-D results were significantly higher (mean=50.21, range: 35.4–107.4) than baseline K-D results (mean=44.3, range 28.4–66.4; p<0.01). TOI K-D results yielded 94% sensitivity and 80% specificity for diagnosing concussions. Four groups emerged from the TOI data. In Group 1, 4/4 were asymptomatic within 24 hours and scores were better (lower) than baseline; Group 2 were asymptomatic within 72 hours and 8/9 had abnormal (poorer) scores; Group 3 were asymptomatic within 11 days and 5/5 had abnormal scores. Group 4 were symptomatic by season’s end and 4/4 had abnormal scores. 18/18 players who RTP had better K-D scores than baseline prior to RTP.

Conclusions The K-D test proved to be useful for concussion diagnosis. Interestingly, the players in Group 1 had normal TOI K-D scores and were asymptomatic in <24 hours. More research is needed and the CFL will continue this next season.

Competing interests None.

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.