AT | MD | PT | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Clinical sign | Cut-off-categories | Percentage (n) | p Value | ||
Sport-specific skills (missing=207) | Normal | 51.5 (69) | 74.5 (41) | 53.7 (22) | Overall: 0.016 |
Mild restriction | 41.8 (56) | 21.8 (12) | 46.3 (19) | MD versus PT: 0.020 | |
Moderate–severe restriction | 6.7 (9) | 3.6 (2) | 0 (0) | MD versus AT: 0.015 | |
PT versus AT: 0.24 | |||||
Pain (missing=74) | Normal | 7.6 (16) | 7.0 (7) | 5.6 (4) | Overall: 0.67 |
Mild restriction | 78.2 (165) | 79.0 (79) | 83.1 (59) | ||
Moderate–severe restriction | 14.2 (30) | 14.0 (14) | 11.3 (8) | ||
Swelling (missing=102) | Normal | 43.2 (70) | 58.5 (48) | 30.5 (18) | Overall: 0.0046 |
Mild restriction | 53.1 (86) | 39.0 (32) | 69.5 (41) | MD versus PT: <0.001 | |
Moderate–severe restriction | 3.7 (6) | 2.4 (2) | 0 (0) | MD versus AT: 0.068 | |
PT versus AT: 0.069 | |||||
Strength (missing=114) | Normal | 53.7 (101) | 57.4 (54) | 53.2 (33) | Overall: 0.89 |
Mild restriction | 44.1 (83) | 39.4 (37) | 45.2 (28) | ||
Moderate–severe restriction | 2.1 (4) | 3.2 (3) | 1.6 (1) | ||
Range of motion (missing=100) | Normal | 53.1 (102) | 57.1 (56) | 54.4 (37) | Overall: 0.35 |
Mild restriction | 34.4 (66) | 28.6 (28) | 39.7 (27) | ||
Moderate–severe restriction | 12.5 (24) | 14.3 (14) | 5.9 (4) | ||
Proprioception/balance (missing=177) | Normal | 52.1 (63) | 49.3 (33) | 50.0 (28) | Overall: 0.94 |
Mild restriction | 41.3 (50) | 44.8 (30) | 46.4 (26) | ||
Moderate–severe restriction | 6.6 (8) | 6.0 (4) | 3.6 (2) |
Raw data are recategorised as normal, mild restriction and moderate–severe restriction (see text for details).
↵* Clinicians who answered ‘do not use’ for a method are excluded from this analysis. Therefore, the total n for each sign is different.
AT, athletic therapist; MD, medicine doctor; PT, physiotherapist.