The effect of divided attention on gait stability following concussion
Introduction
The brain is a highly complex organ that coordinates all functions of the body from intelligence and consciousness to automatic responses such as breathing and circulation. Injuries to the brain, such as concussion, and the resulting symptoms have been recognized since the 16th century (Maroon et al., 2000). Difficulties in definition, recognition, and assessment of concussion have made epidemiological study difficult. However, the yearly incidence of football-related concussions was estimated at 40,000 in 1.1 million high school football players, or 3.6% (Powell and Barber-Foss, 1999). In a study of 141 high school and college football players followed for two years (McCrea et al., 1997), 4.3% experienced mild traumatic brain injury (MTBI). While the high impact nature of football lends itself to high incidences of concussion, the potential for injury to the brain is present in all sports.
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (1999) it is estimated that 5.3 million Americans live with disabilities associated with traumatic brain injury (TBI) at a cost of $56.3 billion annually. Many of these injuries fall under the category of MTBI (Bailes and Hudson, 2001). While no injury to the brain should be considered minor (Cantu, 1997) there is a prevailing notion that one concussion results in little permanent neurological damage (Maroon et al., 2000). However, rate of recovery, even from a single concussion, is highly individual, and standardized recovery curves are not readily available to physicians and certified athletic trainers to make objective return-to-play decisions (McCrory et al., 2000). Given the potentially serious consequences of concussions, the need to identify functional impairment following a brain injury is critical to prevent re-injury during the period of recovery. While many neuropsychological tests have been developed to assess cognitive performance (Wojtys et al., 1999), relatively little information is available on dynamic motor task performance following concussion. Some patients report symptoms long after the injury even though their cognitive deficits are small (Alves et al., 1986).
Most biomechanical studies on MTBI to date have largely been limited to postural sway during quiet standing or during standing with altered sensory inputs (Geurts et al., 1996; Geurts et al., 1999; Guskiewicz et al., 1996; Ingersoll and Armstrong, 1992; Lahat et al., 1996; Lehmann et al., 1990; Rubin et al., 1995; Wade et al., 1997; Wober et al., 1993). Guskiewicz et al. (1996) concluded that participants with MTBI demonstrated impaired postural stability for one to three days following injury. Guskiewicz et al. (2001) also reported no relationship between symptoms, performance on tests of cognitive function, and static postural stability. The data suggested that recovery of motor function, as demonstrated by static postural control following MTBI, might be independent of cognitive recovery.
Recent studies have reported effects of moderate to severe TBI on gait and dynamic stability (Basford et al., 2003; McFadyen et al., 2003; Chou et al., 2004). Such post-TBI individuals, even with a normal neurological and musculoskeletal examination, were found to walk with increased caution, demonstrating a significantly slower walking speed and shorter stride length. Compared to matched controls, patients with TBI also displayed a significantly greater and faster medio-lateral center of mass (CoM) motion, which has been demonstrated to be a sensitive measure of dynamic stability (Basford et al., 2003; Chou et al., 2004). However, most of the participants included in these studies suffered a moderate to severe TBI (initial Glasgow Coma Scale ⩽ 12) and complained of instability during gait at the time of testing (duration of injury: 2–22 months). Similar information on gait and dynamic stability is currently not available for young adults following a concussion.
Maintenance of balance and limb coordination during locomotion or sport activities requires a complex interaction of sensory input and motor output. Sensory systems monitor the location of the whole body CoM relative to the foot-ground center of pressure (CoP), provide orientation in space, and monitor the environment. Motor systems provide appropriate coordinated muscular activation and force generation. When the brain is engaged the effect is synchronized movement. This dynamic interaction is vividly portrayed in athletics. But when a person is required to perform synchronized movement with divided attention, the effect is not as well understood. Previous studies have found that attentional demands increase as physical requirements increase. Lajoie et al. (1993) found that response time to an auditory stimulus were shortest when physical demands were less (sitting) and increased as the task demands increased (standing and walking). They also found that the response times were greater in the more unstable single-stance phase of gait compared to double-stance. It has been reported further that divided attention reduced obstacle avoidance performance while walking (Weerdesteyn et al., 2003). Ebersbach et al. (1995) also demonstrated that mean digit recall was greater during quiet stance than during walking. However, to date little is known about the effect of divided attention on gait in persons with recent brain injury.
A functionally challenging dual task, such as varying conditions of mental concentration while walking, may prove to be related to post-concussion status and provide more pertinent information regarding the optimal time for return to play. The overall goal of this study was to determine the effect of divided attention on balance control during gait in persons who have recently suffered a concussion. It was hypothesized that, when compared to uninjured controls, concussed subjects would demonstrate deficits in maintenance of dynamic stability, as indicated by an increased frontal plane CoM motion, while performing a concurrent cognitive task during walking.
Section snippets
Methods
Twenty college-aged volunteers served as subjects for this study. The subject groups consisted of ten college-aged men and women who had sustained a concussion (CONC) and ten uninjured controls (NORM). Each CONC subject was matched to a NORM subject by age, height, weight, and physical activity profile. All participants were involved in intercollegiate, club, intramural sports, or recreational activities. All CONCs sustained a Grade 2 concussion as defined by the American Academy of Neurology
Results
No significant differences in anthropometric data were observed between the two subject groups (independent-samples t-test: Age P = 0.83; height P = 0.96; weight P = 0.44; Table 2). Testing commenced within 48 h after injury for all subjects with concussion with the exception of one subject who began testing at 50 h post-concussion.
During the dual-task condition both groups displayed a gait pattern with a significantly slower gait velocity (GV; P < 0.001), shorter stride length (SL; P < 0.001), and longer
Discussion
The purpose of this study was to determine how a concussion affects dynamic balance under conditions of divided and undivided attention soon after the occurrence of injury. It was hypothesized that concussed individuals would demonstrate less stability while performing a concurrent cognitive task during walking than uninjured normal controls. Results from this study revealed that concussed subjects had to conservatively adjust their whole body CoM motion to maintain dynamic stability when
Acknowledgement
This study was supported by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (R49/CCR021735 and CCR023203). The authors gratefully acknowledge the assistance of Robert Catena in data collection.
References (32)
- et al.
An assessment of gait and balance deficits after traumatic brain injury
Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation
(2003) Athletic head injuries
Clinics in Sports Medicine
(1997)- et al.
Medio-lateral motion of the center of mass during obstacle crossing distinguishes elderly individuals with imbalance
Gait and Posture
(2003) - et al.
Dynamic instability during obstacle crossing following traumatic brain injury
Gait and Posture
(2004) - et al.
Is postural control associated with mental functioning in persistent post-concussion syndrome?
Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation
(1999) - et al.
Identification of static and dynamic postural instability following traumatic brain injury
Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation
(1996) - et al.
Can motion of individual body segments identify dynamic instability in the elderly?
Clinical Biomechanics
(2003) - et al.
Postural stability by computerized posturography in minor head trauma
Pediatric Neurology
(1996) - et al.
Center of mass velocity-position predictions for balance control
Journal of Biomechanics
(1997) - et al.
Changes in postural sway and performance of functional tasks during rehabilitation after traumatic brain injury
Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation
(1997)
A FORTRAN package for generalized, cross-validatory spline smoothing and differentiation
Advances in Engineering Software
Understanding posttraumatic symptoms after minor head injury
Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation
Neurology
Classification of sport-related head trauma: a spectrum of mild to severe injury
Journal of Athletic Training
The mental status examination
American Family Physician
Cited by (116)
A predictive paradigm for identifying elevated musculoskeletal injury risks after sport-related concussion
2022, Sports Orthopaedics and TraumatologyImpaired motor control after sport-related concussion could increase risk for musculoskeletal injury: Implications for clinical management and rehabilitation
2021, Journal of Sport and Health ScienceConcussion - Part I: The need for a multifaceted assessment
2019, Musculoskeletal Science and Practice