Article Text

Download PDFPDF

Role of exercise counselling in health promotion
  1. Abby C King
  1. Stanford University School of Medicine Palo Alto CA 94304-1583, USA

    Statistics from

    Despite the clear health benefits that can be attained through adopting a more active lifestyle, most adults in the United Kingdom as well as other industrial nations remain underactive. Faced with this epidemic, there is a growing need for physical activity interventions that can be widely disseminated to all segments of the population across the lifespan.

    One promising avenue for physical activity counselling and support lies with the primary care doctor and other health care professionals. The strengths of incorporating physical activity advice and support as part of routine health care include the ability to reach a substantial portion of the population repeatedly over time, the consistency and continuity of message content and delivery, and the willingness among patients to act on their doctor's advice.1,2 Despite these strengths, however, a number of barriers to physical activity counselling in primary care have been documented, including lack of time, reimbursement, and training in physical activity or behaviour change counselling.3 Although such barriers present continuing challenges to the health promotion and health care fields, the potential public health impact that primary care settings can have on health behaviour change, including physical activity, merits continued investigation.

    Although a relatively large body of research exists on advice and counselling by doctors for other health behaviours, such as smoking, relatively little systematic research has been conducted to date on physical activity promotion in primary care. The studies that have been undertaken have taken advantage of a growing body of knowledge, underscoring the utility of applying empirically supported behavioural strategies in facilitating physical activity change. Such behavioural strategies, derived primarily from social cognitive theory and its derivatives, include: identifying specific practical physical activity goals tailored to the patient's needs and circumstances; structuring initial patient expectations so that they are realistic; identifying those benefits related to becoming more physically active that are most germane to the patient's own health status; encouraging the patient to keep track of his or her own physical activity patterns through simple self monitoring tools; and providing continual interest, encouragement, and support for physical activity. Some of these behavioural strategies have been used in studies in which primary care doctors have been trained to deliver brief advice and counselling on physical activity, with encouraging results in the short term.4,5 In one study, for example, a written goal oriented exercise prescription from general practitioners, in addition to verbal advice, was particularly effective in promoting increased physical activity over a six week period.6 More discrepant results obtained from longer term multiple risk factor programmes, however, suggest that more intensive interventions may be needed to obtain longer term effects in at least some segments of the population. Such interventions could include the use of health educators and professionals in addition to the doctor. Health educators and other allied health professionals can provide a level of advice and counselling beyond that which doctors, constrained by time and similar barriers, are typically able to deliver.7 One promising approach awaiting more extensive investigation involves using brief advice from the doctor as a means of setting the stage for physical activity change in conjunction with specific referral to other health care based or community based health educators or providers. In this way, the perceived credibility and authority of the doctor can be harnessed as a catalyst for change, while the very real time constraints facing many doctors are recognised.8 The challenge remains to structure the referral network effectively such that patients will successfully follow through with the referral. To maximise the potential benefits of this type of referral network, continuing communication between the doctor and referral source is essential.

    In addition, the studies targeting primary care providers have focused almost exclusively on doctors involved in family practice and internal medicine. Yet, other primary care specialties, such as paediatrics and obstetrics-gynaecology, reach important segments of the population for whom physical activity information and messages are particularly relevant. Future research should target the full range of primary care practice.

    While face to face instruction and counselling for physical activity have traditionally been the norm in most countries, a growing scientific literature has underscored the utility of mediated channels for delivering physical activity advice and information in an efficient, effective, and potentially less costly fashion. For instance, in the United States, at least 13 randomised controlled investigations have systematically evaluated the use of telephone based physical activity advice and support, either in conjunction with or independent of advice from the doctor.7,9,10 The telephone supervised physical activity approach has been shown to be effective in both older and younger adult populations, women as well as men, cardiac patients, older family carers of relatives with dementia, and overweight patients. It has been found to be effective in promoting physical activity of various types—for example, endurance, strength, flexibility, general conditioning—intensities—for example, moderate intensity exercise, more vigorous exercise—and formats—for example, home based, group based, combinations of home based and group based exercise. Telephone and similar mediated approaches allow both the health professional and the patient a level of convenience and flexibility that is often diminished or lacking in group based physical activity regimens.

    In summary, to reach the public health goals on physical activity in the United Kingdom, United States, Australia, and other countries continued efforts to involve primary care providers and other health professionals as active facilitators of the physical activity message are strongly indicated. Primary care advice in conjunction with referral to appropriate community organisations may help to facilitate the long term increases in physical activity participation that are critical for health promotion and disease prevention. Telephone and other mediated approaches to physical activity promotion provide a promising avenue for programme delivery, in primary care as well as other community settings.


    View Abstract

    Request Permissions

    If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.