Skip to main content
Subscribe
Log In
More
Log in via Institution
Log in via OpenAthens
Log in via your Society
Select your society
ACMSE
ACPSEM
ACSEP
AMSSM
BASEM
BASRAT
CASEM
CLINICAL EDGE
FSEM
GISSPORT
IOC
OSCA
SASMA
SGMS
SMA
SPC
SPNZ
SSMS
SSPA
SST
SUFT
VSG
Log in using your username and password
For personal accounts OR managers of institutional accounts
Username
*
Password
*
Forgot your log in details?
Register a new account?
Forgot
your user name or password?
Basket
Search
More
Search for this keyword
Advanced search
Latest content
Current issue
Archive
For authors
Resources
About
New editors
Search for this keyword
Advanced search
Close
More
Main menu
Latest content
Current issue
Archive
For authors
Resources
About
New editors
Subscribe
Log in
More
Log in via Institution
Log in via OpenAthens
Log in via your Society
Select your society
ACMSE
ACPSEM
ACSEP
AMSSM
BASEM
BASRAT
CASEM
CLINICAL EDGE
FSEM
GISSPORT
IOC
OSCA
SASMA
SGMS
SMA
SPC
SPNZ
SSMS
SSPA
SST
SUFT
VSG
Log in using your username and password
For personal accounts OR managers of institutional accounts
Username
*
Password
*
Forgot your log in details?
Register a new account?
Forgot
your user name or password?
BMJ Journals
You are here
Home
Archive
Volume 36, Issue 2
To review or not to review, that is the question
Email alerts
Article metrics
Article menu
Article
Text
Article
info
Citation
Tools
Share
Rapid Responses
Article
metrics
Alerts
This article has a correction. Please see:
Expression of concern about content of which Dr Paul McCrory is a single author - October 10, 2022
PDF
Editorial
To review or not to review, that is the question
Free
Online download statistics by month:
Online download statistics by month: March 2002 to May 2023
Abstract
Full
Pdf
Mar 2002
0
48
4
Apr 2002
0
34
3
May 2002
0
40
2
Jun 2002
0
20
3
Jul 2002
0
4
0
Aug 2002
0
6
0
Sep 2002
0
12
0
Oct 2002
0
19
2
Nov 2002
0
12
0
Jan 2003
0
2
0
Feb 2003
0
4
3
Mar 2003
0
9
4
Apr 2003
0
5
0
May 2003
0
5
2
Jun 2003
0
3
0
Jul 2003
0
101
0
Aug 2003
0
6
1
Sep 2003
0
7
3
Oct 2003
0
5
0
Nov 2003
0
7
0
Dec 2003
0
5
0
Jan 2004
0
80
1
Feb 2004
0
85
1
Mar 2004
0
59
1
Apr 2004
0
5
0
May 2004
0
10
1
Jun 2004
0
30
0
Jul 2004
0
47
1
Aug 2004
0
47
5
Sep 2004
0
21
2
Oct 2004
7
15
4
Nov 2004
8
12
3
Dec 2004
8
23
1
Jan 2005
5
21
7
Feb 2005
8
29
8
Mar 2005
12
37
6
Apr 2005
4
20
3
May 2005
2
18
1
Jun 2005
0
25
2
Jul 2005
5
26
9
Aug 2005
3
26
9
Sep 2005
2
18
2
Oct 2005
4
26
5
Nov 2005
2
15
4
Dec 2005
2
5
1
Jan 2006
2
21
18
Feb 2006
1
16
22
Mar 2006
1
7
14
Apr 2006
0
10
6
May 2006
2
23
2
Jun 2006
1
16
2
Jul 2006
0
18
0
Aug 2006
0
10
0
Sep 2006
3
14
0
Oct 2006
6
11
1
Nov 2006
1
10
1
Dec 2006
3
7
2
Jan 2007
2
11
3
Feb 2007
4
14
1
Mar 2007
1
13
8
Apr 2007
9
4
1
May 2007
5
6
3
Jun 2007
10
5
4
Jul 2007
8
8
0
Aug 2007
6
6
2
Sep 2007
4
4
1
Oct 2007
3
1
2
Nov 2007
0
1
0
Dec 2007
4
4
2
Jan 2008
1
2
1
Feb 2008
7
4
0
Mar 2008
2
3
3
Apr 2008
5
6
2
May 2008
4
6
5
Jun 2008
4
3
0
Jul 2008
4
4
3
Aug 2008
2
1
0
Sep 2008
5
2
1
Oct 2008
2
0
1
Nov 2008
4
2
1
Dec 2008
1
3
1
Jan 2009
4
6
2
Feb 2009
2
4
1
Mar 2009
3
4
0
Apr 2009
1
0
0
May 2009
4
1
0
Jun 2009
2
0
0
Jul 2009
6
0
0
Aug 2009
1
2
1
Sep 2009
1
2
0
Oct 2009
2
2
0
Nov 2009
3
1
1
Dec 2009
8
2
2
Jan 2010
1
2
2
Mar 2010
0
1
0
Apr 2010
3
4
0
May 2010
2
0
1
Jun 2010
3
0
3
Jul 2010
1
1
431
Aug 2010
3
0
1
Sep 2010
7
1
0
Oct 2010
2
10
0
Nov 2010
8
5
0
Dec 2010
2
1
1
Jan 2011
4
1
1
Feb 2011
6
1
0
Mar 2011
3
0
0
Apr 2011
3
2
0
May 2011
5
0
1
Jun 2011
10
0
1
Jul 2011
10
2
1
Aug 2011
14
0
0
Sep 2011
4
0
0
Oct 2011
6
0
0
Nov 2011
18
2
1
Dec 2011
10
7
3
Jan 2012
7
6
2
Feb 2012
6
3
4
Mar 2012
6
7
7
Apr 2012
9
7
3
May 2012
4
4
5
Jun 2012
2
4
3
Jul 2012
7
8
5
Aug 2012
4
5
5
Sep 2012
5
1
4
Oct 2012
7
6
5
Nov 2012
2
1
1
Dec 2012
3
3
1
Jan 2013
21
13
3
Feb 2013
4
1
2
Mar 2013
0
6
1
Apr 2013
3
5
1
May 2013
3
6
0
Jun 2013
0
1
0
Jul 2013
5
3
2
Aug 2013
4
6
0
Sep 2013
5
8
3
Oct 2013
2
4
0
Nov 2013
5
5
0
Dec 2013
3
3
3
Jan 2014
2
1
7
Feb 2014
6
5
1
Mar 2014
5
10
1
Apr 2014
3
11
1
May 2014
2
3
6
Jun 2014
2
10
2
Jul 2014
7
67
2
Aug 2014
0
12
11
Sep 2014
1
18
10
Oct 2014
1
8
16
Nov 2014
0
22
22
Dec 2014
0
16
10
Jan 2015
3
6
1
Feb 2015
5
7
3
Mar 2015
1
4
0
Apr 2015
4
9
0
May 2015
2
5
1
Jun 2015
8
6
2
Jul 2015
1
1
0
Aug 2015
2
3
1
Sep 2015
4
6
2
Oct 2015
0
3
0
Nov 2015
3
4
0
Dec 2015
4
6
1
Jan 2016
3
8
2
Feb 2016
7
5
2
Mar 2016
4
1
7
Apr 2016
5
3
2
May 2016
2
3
1
Jun 2016
3
1
0
Jul 2016
10
9
6
Aug 2016
3
1
0
Sep 2016
10
6
2
Oct 2016
20
2
4
Nov 2016
19
4
1
Dec 2016
16
4
1
Jan 2017
29
7
6
Feb 2017
4
1
1
Mar 2017
3
6
0
Apr 2017
0
11
0
May 2017
5
13
0
Jun 2017
5
11
5
Jul 2017
6
4
1
Aug 2017
15
8
1
Sep 2017
12
12
0
Oct 2017
23
15
2
Nov 2017
16
12
0
Dec 2017
19
15
0
Jan 2018
15
13
0
Feb 2018
15
11
4
Mar 2018
31
17
1
Apr 2018
18
12
0
May 2018
17
14
1
Jun 2018
13
12
0
Jul 2018
12
12
2
Aug 2018
7
7
1
Sep 2018
10
10
1
Oct 2018
19
20
2
Nov 2018
13
12
0
Dec 2018
20
20
2
Jan 2019
19
16
1
Feb 2019
11
11
0
Mar 2019
16
14
5
Apr 2019
14
13
3
May 2019
7
6
3
Jun 2019
8
8
9
Jul 2019
9
9
4
Aug 2019
15
13
4
Sep 2019
8
7
3
Oct 2019
11
11
1
Nov 2019
18
16
3
Dec 2019
5
5
2
Jan 2020
23
23
3
Feb 2020
14
13
2
Mar 2020
13
13
7
Apr 2020
19
18
7
May 2020
24
24
5
Jun 2020
11
11
2
Jul 2020
15
15
1
Aug 2020
10
10
3
Sep 2020
18
18
3
Oct 2020
16
16
11
Nov 2020
11
11
0
Dec 2020
15
14
2
Jan 2021
15
15
1
Feb 2021
14
13
3
Mar 2021
9
9
3
Apr 2021
9
7
1
May 2021
5
5
3
Jun 2021
11
11
0
Jul 2021
19
19
2
Aug 2021
6
6
4
Sep 2021
12
12
2
Oct 2021
14
10
15
Nov 2021
13
12
9
Dec 2021
6
5
0
Jan 2022
14
14
6
Feb 2022
11
11
3
Mar 2022
29
20
13
Apr 2022
11
11
1
May 2022
31
32
17
Jun 2022
22
22
4
Jul 2022
18
20
4
Aug 2022
31
25
5
Sep 2022
22
22
4
Oct 2022
26
25
4
Nov 2022
16
15
4
Dec 2022
12
12
0
Jan 2023
8
8
5
Feb 2023
30
29
3
Mar 2023
8
7
0
Apr 2023
7
6
2
May 2023
14
14
5
Total
1736
2807
1096
Read the full text or download the PDF:
Subscribe
Log in
Log in via Institution
Log in via OpenAthens
Log in via your Society
Select your society
ACMSE
ACPSEM
ACSEP
AMSSM
BASEM
BASRAT
CASEM
CLINICAL EDGE
FSEM
GISSPORT
IOC
OSCA
SASMA
SGMS
SMA
SPC
SPNZ
SSMS
SSPA
SST
SUFT
VSG
Log in using your username and password
For personal accounts OR managers of institutional accounts
Username
*
Password
*
Forgot your log in details?
Register a new account?
Forgot
your user name or password?
PDF