Article Text

Download PDFPDF

Testosterone and doping control
  1. C Saudan,
  2. N Baume,
  3. N Robinson,
  4. L Avois,
  5. P Mangin,
  6. M Saugy
  1. Swiss Laboratory for Doping Analyses, Institute of Legal Medicine, Lausanne, Switzerland
  1. Correspondence to:
 M Saugy
 Swiss Laboratory for Doping Analyses, Institute of Legal Medicine, Lausanne, Switzerland; martial.saugy{at}chuv.ch

Abstract

Background and objectives: Anabolic steroids are synthetic derivatives of testosterone, modified to enhance its anabolic actions (promotion of protein synthesis and muscle growth). They have numerous side effects, and are on the International Olympic Committee’s list of banned substances. Gas chromatography-mass spectrometry allows identification and characterisation of steroids and their metabolites in the urine but may not distinguish between pharmaceutical and natural testosterone. Indirect methods to detect doping include determination of the testosterone/epitestosterone glucuronide ratio with suitable cut-off values. Direct evidence may be obtained with a method based on the determination of the carbon isotope ratio of the urinary steroids. This paper aims to give an overview of the use of anabolic-androgenic steroids in sport and methods used in anti-doping laboratories for their detection in urine, with special emphasis on doping with testosterone.

Methods: Review of the recent literature of anabolic steroid testing, athletic use, and adverse effects of anabolic-androgenic steroids.

Results: Procedures used for detection of doping with endogenous steroids are outlined. The World Anti-Doping Agency provided a guide in August 2004 to ensure that laboratories can report, in a uniform way, the presence of abnormal profiles of urinary steroids resulting from the administration of testosterone or its precursors, androstenediol, androstenedione, dehydroepiandrosterone or a testosterone metabolite, dihydrotestosterone, or a masking agent, epitestosterone.

Conclusions: Technology developed for detection of testosterone in urine samples appears suitable when the substance has been administered intramuscularly. Oral administration leads to rapid pharmacokinetics, so urine samples need to be collected in the initial hours after intake. Thus there is a need to find specific biomarkers in urine or plasma to enable detection of long term oral administration of testosterone.

  • DHEA, dehydroepiandrosterone
  • IOC, International Olympic Committee
  • IRMS, isotopic ratio mass spectrometry
  • T/E, testosterone to epitestosterone (ratio)
  • WADA, World Anti-Doping Agency
  • testosterone
  • anabolic steroid
  • doping control
View Full Text

Statistics from Altmetric.com

The anabolic steroids are chemical, synthetic derivatives of testosterone modified to enhance the anabolic rather than the androgenic actions of the hormone (fig 1).1 Testosterone is a steroid hormone, synthesised in the human body from cholesterol.2 It serves distinct functions at different stages of life. During embryonic life, androgen action is central to the development of the male phenotype. At puberty, the hormone is responsible for the secondary sexual characteristics that transform boys into men. Testosterone regulates many physiological processes in the adult male including muscle protein metabolism, sexual and cognitive functions, erythropoiesis, plasma lipid levels, and bone metabolism.3

Figure 1

 Molecular structure of testosterone.

PHARMACEUTICAL ACTION OF ANABOLIC STEROIDS

Soon after testosterone was isolated in 1935, it was discovered that it is virtually inactive when taken orally. After oral ingestion, testosterone is absorbed from the small intestines and passes via the portal vein to the liver where it is rapidly metabolised, mostly to inactive compounds.4,5 The discovery of testosterone has led to the synthesis of anabolic steroids. Chemical modifications of testosterone have been useful pharmacologically to alter the relative anabolic-androgenic potency, slow the rate of inactivation, and change the pattern of metabolism.6 Most oral anabolic-androgenic steroids preparations are 17α-alkylated derivatives of testosterone, which are relatively resistant to hepatic degradation. Esterification of the 17β-hydroxyl group makes the molecule more soluble in lipid vesicles used for injection and hence slows the release of the injected steroid into the circulation. Commonly used 17α-alkyl and 17β-ester derivatives are shown in fig 2.

Figure 2

 Anabolic-androgenic steroids: molecular structure of common 17α-alkyl and 17β-ester derivatives.

Androgenic and anabolic effects of anabolic-androgenic steroids originate from activation of the androgenic receptors. The distinction between these biological effects depends on the organs and target tissues.7 Dihydrotestosterone is responsible of the androgenic effect. This steroid is more potent than testosterone because of increased affinity to the androgen receptor. It is formed from conversion of testosterone by the 5α-reductase enzyme.6 Activity of this enzyme is important in testicles, skin, prostate, intestines, brain, bones, and adipose tissues. Therefore, androgenic effects of anabolic-androgenic steroids predominate in these organs. Anabolic effects will concern organs as muscles, bones, the heart and kidneys. These organs possess little 5α-reductase activity and thus anabolic-androgenic steroids, particularly testosterone, induce protein synthesis, muscle fiber development, erythropoiesis, and stimulation and inhibition of bone growth.8 In addition, anabolic steroids displace glucocorticoids from glucocorticoid receptors and inhibit muscle protein catabolism, leading overall to an anabolic or muscle building effect.9

THERAPEUTIC AND ADVERSE EFFECTS OF ANABOLIC-ANDROGENIC STEROIDS

A number of clinical studies using a variety of experimental designs have shown that the potent anabolic effects of anabolic-androgenic steroids have positive benefits for various patient populations. Physiological replacement doses of testosterone have been used therapeutically to stimulate sexual development in cases of delayed puberty and in cases in which the testicles have been surgically removed, either because of physical injury or because of testicular tumour.8 The major clinical use of anabolic steroids is to inhibit the loss of protein and aid muscle regeneration after major surgery.10

As anabolic-androgenic steroids have effects in several organ systems, multiple side effects can be observed.11,12 The frequency of occurrence and severity of side effects are quite variable and depend on numerous factors such as the type of drug, dosage, duration of use, and the individual sensitivity of the response. The potential adverse effects of anabolic-androgenic steroids can be divided into the following categories: cardiovascular, hepatic, endocrine/reproductive, psychological, and tendon injury.13,14

USE OF ANABOLIC-ANDROGENIC STEROIDS BY ATHLETES

Information on doses and modes of administration of anabolic-androgenic steroids used by athletes to increase their performances is relatively sparse.13 It is known that bodybuilders follow a typical pattern called “stacking”, based on administration of several oral and injectable anabolic-androgenic steroids during cycles lasting 4–12 weeks. The advantage of this practice has been demonstrated recently.12 The drug dosages range from 250 mg to 3500 mg per week and are therefore up to 40 times the recommended therapeutic dosage.14 However, some studies have described the effect of polypharmacy practice at therapeutic doses in weight lifters,15 and endurance and sprint athletes.16

Psychologically, administration of anabolic-androgenic steroids may affect behaviour. Increased testosterone levels in the blood are associated with masculine behaviour, aggressiveness, and increase of sexual desire.17 Increased aggressiveness might be beneficial for athletic training, but might also lead to overt violence outside the gym or the track. Other side effects of anabolic-androgenic steroids are euphoria, confusion, sleeping disorders, pathological anxiety, paranoia, and hallucinations. Some of these psychological effects could be beneficial for athletes by improving their performance. Indeed, it is more and more often suggested that the intake of small doses of anabolic-androgenic steroids, particularly testosterone, could lead to a lower fatigue levels, a better recovery, and therefore to higher training charge, and finally to a faster increase in physical performance. In a recent controlled study including a placebo group, the effect of multiple oral doses of testosterone undecanoate on mood state during one month of intense endurance training was assessed.18 It emerged that multiple oral intake of testosterone undecanoate could have an impact on recovery from physical strain in a hard training period. In some cases, however, it appeared that mood changes was the result of a placebo effect.

ANABOLIC STEROID TESTING

Background

The medical commissions of major international sport federations and of the International Olympic Committee (IOC) have been concerned over the misuse of doping agents in the sports community since the beginning of the 1970s. At that time, these commissions developed a dope control procedure whose fundamental elements are still valid today:

  1. selection of athletes

  2. urine sample collection procedure

  3. analysis of the A sample in an accredited IOC laboratory

  4. if the A sample gives positive analytical results, analysis of the B sample in the same accredited laboratory.

The hearing of the athlete is then organised by the medical commission, where the eventual sanctions against the athlete are decided.

International organisations have established a list of substance classes and methods that athletes are forbidden to use during competition and training. The latest list established by the World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA)19 for 2006 includes two types of steroid:

  • the typically exogenous steroids, of which the main examples are given in fig 2

  • the typically endogenous steroids—for example, androstenediol, androstenedione, dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA), dihydrotestosterone, testosterone and related substances.

According to the 2004 WADA statistics, about 36% of the positive analytical finding declared by the accredited anti-doping laboratories concerned anabolic-androgenic steroids. Among the 1191 positive cases, it is worth mentioning that testosterone and nandrolone were the most used substances (33% and 29% of the cases, respectively).

Testing for anabolic agents in the urine of athletes was implemented on a large scale during the 1976 Olympic Games in Montreal and was mainly based at that time on radioimmunoassay techniques. The techniques for the identification and characterisation of steroids and their metabolites in the urine have improved considerably during the past two decades. This improvement is largely due to the use of gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) techniques. Today, most anti-doping laboratories use techniques based on the solid phase extraction of the urine sample, followed by chemical modifications prior to GC-MS analysis.20 The confirmation procedure in an anti-doping analysis consists of demonstrating unequivocally that there is a correspondence between the GC and MS properties of the anabolic agent or its metabolite with those of an authentic pure standard or of a reference excretion study.21

The T/E ratio

Detection of exogenous substances means identifying the parent compound or at least one metabolite. Nevertheless, with substances that are produced endogenously, such as testosterone, the presence of the substance alone cannot be considered to be an offence by itself. Moreover, a cut-off value for testosterone concentration cannot be used because of large observed interindividual and intraindividual urinary concentrations of the steroid. However, intake of testosterone causes characteristic changes in the pattern of steroids excreted in the urine. Based on studies of athlete populations, the IOC adopted in 1983 a ratio of testosterone to epitestosterone glucuronides (T/E) with an authorised upper limit of 6.0 as a criterion for the administration of testosterone. Since epitestosterone is only a minor product of the metabolism of testosterone and does not increase after testosterone administration, the resulting effect is an increase in the T/E ratio.22 In several studies, the distribution of results in Caucasian athlete populations shows generally a mean T/E ratio less than 2.0,20,23 whereas in Asian populations the mean T/E ratio is significantly lower. The IOC rules clearly indicate that a T/E ratio greater than 6.0 constituted an offence unless there was evidence that this ratio is due to a physiological or pathological condition—for example, low epitestosterone excretion, androgen producing tumour, and enzyme deficiencies.24 In addition, it has been observed that hepatic metabolism of steroid hormones may be altered by administration of substances as ethanol with the resulting effect of modifying significantly the T/E ratio.24

Other urinary tests such as ketoconazole test25 and the testosterone glucuronide to luteinising hormone (T/LH) ratio26 have been developed to deter doping with testosterone or a precursor. However, there is still a lack of a reference method for measuring and identifying LH and therefore the T/LH ratio is less effective in meeting legal challenges.27 Detection of testosterone esters in plasma and hairs have been also suggested as promising solutions to deter doping with injectable preparations of testosterone esters.28,29 Nevertheless, doping controls are still limited on urine samples for detection of doping with these substances. Regarding hair analysis, it has been found that these T esters are poorly stored in hairs and therefore only massive and repeated use of these substances may be detected in this biological matrix.30

What is already known about this topic

Anabolic steroids were added to the IOC’s list of banned substances in 1975. Anabolic steroids are synthetic derivatives of testosterone, modified to enhance the anabolic rather than the androgenic actions of the hormone. Detection of substances that are not supposed to be produced by the body leads to an adverse analytical finding. Conversely, for the endogenous hormones such as testosterone or DHEA, it is mandatory to determine the origin of the steroid.

Before a sample is declared as consistent with doping with testosterone or a precursor, further investigations are conducted, such as a longitudinal study of the urinary T/E ratio. As a first step, comparison with previous values should be done; if no previous values are available, several additional urine samples are analysed over a short period of time. This longitudinal study may represent a useful tool for discriminating the false positive (naturally elevated T/E ratios) results from those due to manipulation of the urine.23 According to guidance given by WADA in 2004, urine samples should be now submitted to isotopic ratio mass spectrometry (IRMS) if the T/E is greater or equal to 4.0 and testosterone, testosterone metabolites, epitestosterone, and DHEA concentrations are greater than fixed cut-off concentrations.31

Carbon isotope ratio

Even if longitudinal study gives good quality information on the potential steroid profile manipulation, there is a lack of definitive proof for the exogenous application of natural steroids. One possible way of solving this problem is the ratio of the two stable carbon isotopes 13C/12C, which can allow the differentiation of natural and synthetic steroids. As exogenous testosterone or precursors contain less 13C than their endogenous homologues, it is expected that urinary steroids with a low 13C/12C ratio originate from pharmaceutical sources.32 Endogenous steroids are produced from cholesterol in the body. Cholesterol is derived from an average of a wide variety of feed vegetal and animal precursors or synthesised from precursors of feed origin.

In plant tissue, the main source of variation in 13C/12C isotopic ratio is derived from the different photosynthetic pathways for carbon dioxide fixation. Plants incorporate carbon dioxide via photosynthesis by three different mechanisms: the Calvin cycle (C3) pathway, the Hatch-Slack (C4) pathway and the crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) pathway. The C3 pathway results in a large change in the carbon isotope proportions relative to atmospheric carbon dioxide and hence discriminates more strongly against the heavier isotope 13C compared with the C4 pathway. Main representatives of C3 group are wheat, rice, potato, barley, grape, oats, and sugar beet, whereas maize, sugar cane, millet, and pineapple are the important species of the C4 group.33 The difference in the 13C enrichment of food products in the diet and even in the food chain is caused by different contribution of naturally 13C-enriched constituents. Because maize, millet, and sugar cane (C4 plants) are the common food ingredients in some areas of Africa, it is expected that the basic 13C enrichment of the body store will be high for local populations.34 It is known that urine samples collected from a country such as Kenya have a higher content of 13C in steroids than western or oceanian countries.35,36

The method for determining the isotopic composition of the relevant analyte includes gas chromatography, a subsequent combustion to CO2, and finally, mass spectrometric analysis of this gas in a special multi-collector mass spectrometer (gas chromatography/combustion/isotope ratio mass spectrometry, GC/C/IRMS).37 The 13C/12C value of testosterone or that of its metabolites will be measured and compared with that of urinary reference steroids within the sample to take into account variation in an athlete’s diet.38,39 In addition, it should be emphasised that the 13C/12C value of these endogenous reference compounds should not be affected by steroid administration.40,41 The result will be reported as consistent with the administration of a steroid if a significant difference is observed between the 13C/12C values of testosterone metabolites and the endogenous reference compound.42 Following population studies, a different cut-off for positivity was stated in 2004 by the WADA Laboratory Committee. If the IRMS study does not readily indicate exogenous administration, the result should be reported as inconclusive, and if necessary further longitudinal studies are performed.31

What this study adds

Since 1975, several strategies and methods have been developed to deter doping with endogenous steroids. This review described these developments as well as the up to date procedures to be followed to prove administration of testosterone or testosterone prohormones.

It is also worth mentioning that an IRMS method for determining the 13C/12C values for urinary epitestosterone was developed to provide much needed additional support for the detection of doping with epitestosterone.43 Epitestosterone has no clinical use and is not available as a pharmaceutical. This compound is prohibited by sport authorities because its administration will lower the urinary T/E ratio, a marker of testosterone administration.19

CONCLUSION

Although knowledge of androgen steroid metabolism has increased during the past decades and analytical guidance has been provided by sport authorities, detection of doping with testosterone remains a challenge in sport. Clearance of orally administered testosterone esters is rapid, and hence drug testing analysis of the urinary concentration can only be performed in the first hours after administration.42 In order to increase the sensitivity of testosterone esters detection, further investigations have to be conducted for identification of specific biomarkers of this class of doping agent. Beside the difficulty of their detection in urine samples, these substances are used for positive effects on mood states, and also to lower the level of fatigue.

REFERENCES

View Abstract

Footnotes

  • Competing interests: none declared

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.