Article Text

This article has a correction. Please see:

Download PDFPDF

Training and competing in the heat in youth sports: no sweat?
  1. M F Bergeron
  1. Department of Pediatrics, National Youth Sports Health & Safety Institute, Sanford Sports Science Institute, University of South Dakota Sanford School of Medicine, Sanford Health, Sioux Falls, South Dakota, USA
  1. Correspondence to Dr Michael F Bergeron, Sanford Sports Science Institute, 1210 W. 18th Street, Suite 204, Sioux Falls, SD 57104, USA

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.

Good youth sports coaches know well the routine leading up to the early stages of a new season. Assess every child carefully, while identifying and then prioritising the particular gaps and needs, and next outline an approach and plan to effectively advance the process of individual talent and sport development in a positive and enjoyable learning environment, in an effort to make the most of each one's athletic potential and move closer to his or her personal sport aspirations. The coach then begins to work through progressive training and development sessions with each youth athlete and introduces appropriate complementary physical conditioning, while continuing to refine technique and develop viable new competitive tactics. The competition schedule is then carefully planned and the season begins. However, for many young athletes, especially those participating in summer outdoor individual or team sports, environmental heat stress—particularly when the humidity level is high—can have an unanticipated overriding negative impact that can readily undo advances in fitness, movement, speed, power, endurance and competition tactics and goals.

There is widespread recognition of and emphasis (including in the featured consensus statement)1 on the challenges to a young athlete's well-being, safety and sport performance when training and competing in the heat. Moreover, the contributing roles of the environment, acclimatisation status, hydration and other training or competition conditions and scenarios on mitigating or exacerbating exertional heat illness risk have been well clarified. Accordingly, recognised policy statements and guidelines on training and competing in the heat have placed an appropriate emphasis on addressing modifiable factors to meaningfully assist in keeping youth athletes safe and performing well in hot weather.2–4 Yet, undue heat-related problems continue across all sports when youth athletes train and compete in outdoor hot-weather venues. Unfortunately, the response is too often reactionary versus informed anticipation and prevention—that is, parents and coaches usually seek help after a significant problem repeatedly occurred which ultimately cost an important game, match, championship or even sometimes a young athlete's life.

There had been a longstanding perspective that children are less effective in regulating body temperature, incur greater cardiovascular and thermal strain during strenuous physical activity in the heat and thus have lower exercise-heat tolerance compared with adults. This view was based on early studies showing maturational differences emphasising a lower sweating rate, greater body surface area-to-mass ratio (BSA/M), higher metabolic rate during exercise (lower exercise economy) and a purported lower cardiac output for a given level of exercise in children.5–10 However, closer examination indicates that muscle efficiency is not influenced by biological maturation, adult–child differences in exercise economy disappear with equal relative exercise intensity, cardiac responses are similar and equally effective in prepubertal and mature participants and any potential disadvantage related to BSA/M and greater heat gain from the environment would be a comparable liability for children only in extreme heat conditions.11 Importantly, minor variability and differences in net metabolic heat production in children compared with adults are offset by higher levels of relative (to body mass) evaporative cooling and sweating efficiency, thus yielding lower mass-dependent heat storage.12 Accordingly, the contemporary perspective is that adequately hydrated and heat-acclimatised youth athletes are not at a distinguishing cardiovascular or thermoregulatory disadvantage compared to similarly fit, hydrated and acclimatised adults during exercise in the heat. This is not to say that environmental heat stress is benign to youth; but, it is clear, just as with adults, that careful planning and preparation and beginning a bout of training or competition in a well-rested and adequately hydrated, nourished and acclimatised state can effectively extend the range of exercise-heat tolerance for healthy young athletes and minimise the negative effects on sport performance and well-being.13 However, with the transition from early childhood through late adolescence, athletes, parents, coaches and event administrators need to be cognisant of and suitably accommodate the greater sweat losses and potential increases in thermal strain and exertional heat illness risk that accompany physical growth, maturation and enhanced fitness and athletic/sport skill.

As a youth athlete grows, physically develops and matures, more heat is produced from a greater muscle mass and more mature sweat glands appropriately fulfil their increased sweat production capacity during vigorous physical activity, resulting in a greater thermal load and an increase in sweat fluid and electrolyte (primarily sodium) losses, respectively. Unlike as in a young child or early adolescent, total body water and exchangeable sodium deficits, resulting from extensive sweating during a single training session, game, match or race, can be comparatively more substantial in a mid-teen to late-teen athlete.14 These sizable deficits and sometimes greater levels of thermal strain are more likely to negatively affect performance and increase the risk for incurring exertional heat illness in the ongoing bout of activity or the next one, if adequate measures are not taken and/or there is insufficient time to offset these greater challenges and aptly recover.15–19 Moreover, longer hard workouts and contests that are often characteristic with more physically developed, fit and skilled older adolescent athletes can result in greater levels of muscle damage and a potential carry-over effect that could increase thermal strain during the next training session or contest.20 Parents and coaches often grumble, for example—“She/he never had these problems in the heat as a 12-year-old!” This is often a case of not recognising and fully appreciating the naturally occurring progressive changes in metabolic heat production and sweating with growth, maturation and physical development through adolescence to young adulthood and the greater consequent requirement for more intentional and precise offsetting measures. Coaches need to adjust workouts and parents and coaches need to be mindful of and, at times, alter the competition loads and always firmly emphasise proper recovery in response to the heat for all age groups in youth sports; however, they need to be particularly mindful of the progressively greater challenges as a young athlete gets older and trains and competes at a higher level. This might seem obvious and seemingly should be naturally accommodated by inherent behavioral changes (eg, self-prompted more deliberate and aggressive rehydration) by the athlete—but these greater hydration and recovery challenges are often not sufficiently managed until problems are encountered, individualised needs are determined and more specific offsetting strategies are effectively implemented.

What can coaches do?

It is important to follow recognised general guidelines and recommended accommodations for keeping youth athletes safe and performing well in the heat.2–4 Coaches should also anticipate and appropriately adjust for changes in workloads (harder, longer and more frequent training and competition, resulting in greater metabolic challenges and thermal strain), sweating capacity and consequent greater body water and electrolyte losses and related safety and performance challenges, as a youth athlete grows, physically develops and matures. In response, providing more frequent rehydration and recovery breaks during training and practice sessions is fitting. Moreover, ample prehydration should be more strongly encouraged, along with a more insistent emphasis that sweat-prompted electrolyte deficits after training and competition must be deliberately and fully offset on a daily basis. Working with other professionals (eg, applied physiologists and sport dietitians) at a university or comprehensive sport research/training centre to identify individual sweat loss challenges and suitable rehydration strategies can be particularly beneficial. Sport physical therapists, biomechanists and youth strength and conditioning specialists can help coaches work on a young athlete's conditioning and functional biomechanics to optimise balanced strength, endurance and movement economy, and thus lessen metabolic heat production and undue thermal strain related to repeated faulty movement mechanics and insufficient fitness. Notably, these deficiencies and related consequences in the heat are often more readily revealed at higher levels of demanding competition. Coaches also need to appreciate that hard workouts and competitions can bias a young athlete for greater thermal strain risk in the next bout of activity—especially with same-day subsequent training sessions and contests. Accordingly, adequate recovery time is essential during the preseason and primary competition period. Coaches should also encourage parents of their young athletes to alert them about any changes in health status and medications, as certain illnesses (current or recent) and medications can alter exercise-heat tolerance and thermal strain.2

What can tournament and other competition event administrators do?

For all competitive events in the heat with all youth age groups, event administrators should ensure that a defined and practiced emergency action plan is in place and on-site facilities and trained personal to administer first aid and cooling if necessary are readily available. However, with older and more skilled youth athletes, greater sweat losses and levels of thermal strain are typically more prevalent. Accordingly, close monitoring of the athletes is essential and more extended rest and recovery times are warranted.

What can sport governing bodies do?

Sufficient education should be provided to coaches, so that they more fully appreciate growth-related, maturation-related and athlete development-related changes in youth athletes specific to hydration and thermal strain challenges. Sport governing bodies should have certain mandatory policies and also provide additional clear up-to-date evidence-informed guidelines for safely and effectively training and competing in the heat.

The message

The negative effects imposed by the heat on sport safety and performance can be appreciably lessened if offsetting measures (eg, adequate hydration, appropriate scheduling and conduct of training and contests, including recovery time) are suitably implemented to reduce exertional heat illness risk, as contributing conditions and circumstances warrant. So, is training and competing in the heat no sweat in youth sports? No, sweating, thermal strain and exertional heat illness risk can be significant and are increasingly greater and the observed effects often more extensive during vigorous exercise in the heat as young athletes grow and mature…but, the heat can be little-to-no problem in a wide range of conditions, if modifiable risk is adequately minimised and youth athletes are suitably prepared and given the chance to perform safely and well!

Note: This commentary of practical perspectives and recommendations is based on more than two decades of personal empirical observations and working closely with numerous youth athletes in addressing heat-related challenges during sports training and competition.

References

View Abstract

Footnotes

  • Competing interests None.

  • Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.

Linked Articles

  • Correction
    BMJ Publishing Group Ltd and British Association of Sport and Exercise Medicine