Article Text

Download PDFPDF
Near point convergence and other measures of vestibulo-ocular dysfunction are associated with protracted neurological recovery after sports concussion
  1. Andrew Russman1,2,3,
  2. Susan Linder1,4,
  3. Bob Grey1,2,
  4. Rick Figler1,2,
  5. Jason Cruickshank1,2,
  6. Maureen Lally1,
  7. Jay Alberts1,3,4,
  8. Tanujit Day1,5
  1. 1Cleveland Clinic Concussion Centre, Cleveland, Ohio, OH
  2. 2Cleveland Clinic Sports Health, Cleveland, Ohio, OH
  3. 3Cleveland Clinic Department of Neurology, Cleveland, Ohio, OH
  4. 4Cleveland Clinic Department of Biomedical Engineering, Cleveland, Ohio, OH
  5. 5Cleveland Clinic Department of Quantitative Health Sciences, Cleveland, Ohio, OH


Objective To characterise specific measures of neurologic dysfunction and recovery associated with concussion in student-athletes using the clinical examination and Cleveland Clinic Concussion application (C3 app).

Design Retrospective observational study

Setting Tertiary sports concussion clinic

Participants 181 student-athletes aged 14-20 diagnosed with concussion by a Cleveland Clinic physician were included.

Interventions C3 data were collected pre-season, and at least once post-injury, along with a physician clinical examination. Individuals were stratified into two groups based on recovery time: typical <21 days (n=97) or protracted 21+ days (n=84).

Outcome measures Near point convergence (NPC) and the following modules of the C3 app were administered: 1) Graded symptom checklist (GSC); 2) Standardised Assessment of Concussion (SAC); 3) Trail Making Test (TMT); 4) Simple and Choice Reaction Time; 5) Processing Speed Test (PST); 6) Biomechanical quantification of balance during the BESS.

Main results At baseline, both groups performed similarly on all C3 modules. Significant differences in NPC were seen among the typical versus protracted group (mean 7.62 cm versus 13.57 cm, p=0.0002). Also, significantly worse performance among the protracted group was seen in GSC (p=0.0001), and measures affected by vestibulo-ocular dysfunction including biomechanical quantification of BESS (p<0.05), simple and choice reaction time (p<0.001), and TMT-B (p=0.01). No difference between groups was noted in BESS errors, SAC, or PST.

Conclusions Abnormal NPC or convergence insufficiency is associated with protracted recovery and should be included in the assessment of student-athletes at baseline and post-injury. Identification of vestibulo-ocular dysfunction helps guide post-concussion assessment, treatment, and return-to-play decision-making.

Competing interests Bob Gray, Rick Figler, Jason Cruickshank, Maureen Lally, Tanujit Day: None. Susan Linder and Jay Alberts have authored intellectual property associated with the mobile application presented in this study.

Statistics from

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.