Article Text
Abstract
Objective 1) Examine the impact of a sports concussion on heart rate variability (HRV) metrics at rest and during a cognitive effort in athletes deemed recovered per usual care; 2) Investigate the association between HRV alterations and cognition.
Design Observational study.
Setting Laboratory.
Participants University athletes who successfully completed step 4 of Zurich return-to-play protocol but had not begun step 5 and teammate controls with no concussion history. History of cardiovascular and neurological disorder, or psychotropic medication/substance use were exclusionary.
Outcome Measures Heart rate and respiration data were recorded during a 5-min rest, followed by a color-shape switch cognitive task with a chest-strap. HRV was analyzed for the last 2-min of rest and 2-min of cognitive effort for time- (SD of NN intervals; root mean square of successive differences) and frequency-domain (low and high frequency), and non-linear approximate entropy.
Main Results 11 concussed [M(SD)age=22.55(2.58); 6 females; M(SD)days=14.64(7.35) post-concussion] and 14 control athletes [M(SD)age=20.57(1.83); 8 females] were included. Heart rate and respiration did not differ between-group, ps>0.648. A 2(Group)×2(Condition) interaction was found for entropy, F(1,23)=5.16, p=0.033, η2=0.183, with concussion group exhibiting greater entropy [M(SD)=0.80(0.09)] during cognitive effort relative to rest [M(SD)=0.71(0.10)], p=0.001, Hedge’s G=1.012[95%CI=0.375,1.626]. The control group did not exhibit this pattern (p=0.286). No other HRV metrics were significant, ps>0.217. Entropy at rest or during cognitive effort were not predictors of accuracy or reaction time on the switch task, ps>0.240.
Conclusions This preliminary data suggests autonomic dysfunction emerges during cognitive effort even when participants are asymptomatic and cleared to return to play.