68 e-Letters

published between 2012 and 2015

  • Re:12 Reasons why the "Physical Activity Myth" paper should not have been published; Request for retraction or modification based on open external peer-review
    Richard S Cooper

    Kelly et al make a number of useful comments about the unfortunate editirial by Malhotra et al. However they too obscure the main point. They use a 2008 NIH document as the key reference to refute the editorialists' claim that exercise does not lead to weight loss.

    What the NIH document actually says -

    The magnitude of weight loss due to physical activity is additive to caloric restriction, but physi...

    Show More
  • If you can click through to this Google+ Community I hope it will help...
    Karim Khan

    It seems very clear that there are two different ways of interpreting the tile of this editorial. BJSM is grateful for the terrific engagement in this important debate - we revel in debate.

    But it's not helpful to have two soliloquys going on so I respectfully suggest there are two basic interpretations of the title.

    Please click through to this Google Community http://ow.ly/PaHbz to see the two inte...

    Show More
  • Review
    Gary Pearce

    This article speaks to the growing need to ensure all work groups including managers take the time to move around more frequently. It is also interesting to note that while this is based on short term studies it will have large long term gains. I will be very interested to see where this research goes in the future. I personally will be looking at ways to partake of this valuable insight in to the need to move away from...

    Show More
  • since you asked for my opinion
    Rebecca A. Silverstein

    Since the web site clearly asked for my opinion, I felt I wanted to share how disappointed I am with this article.

    This article looks like it is simply a copy of a systematic review / metaanalysis published a full 13 months earlier, in september 2013, meaning that the search was current in March 2012.

    The review was criticized at the time of its original publication for being overly optimistic (see the...

    Show More
  • It is time to bust the myth of a catchy title.
    Nathan A Stephens

    Dear Editor,

    It was disappointing to read the recent Editorial by Malhotra et al (1). Whilst the sentiment of the article was perhaps well placed, the desire for a headline grabbing title and catchphrase seems to have taken precedence over clear and honest content. A better title would have been "Three individuals are disgruntled with the marketing campaigns of soft drinks companies", but of course this would...

    Show More
  • Response to paper: It is time to bust the myth of physical inactivity and obesity: you cannot outrun a bad diet
    Robert A Mason

    Dear A Malhotra, T Noakes, and S Phinney,

    Please find below my thoughts on your paper.

    Having read your submission thoroughly I have great praise for its contents. The assessment of the food industry and advertisement is a thorough one. The food industry markets and targets in a morally reprehensible way that has no consideration for people's health at all and is a profit driven machine that needs addr...

    Show More
  • 12 Reasons why the "Physical Activity Myth" paper should not have been published; Request for retraction or modification based on open external peer-review
    Paul Kelly

    To The Editor,

    We read your recent editorial "It is time to bust the myth of physical inactivity and obesity: you cannot outrun a bad diet" (Br J Sports Med doi:10.1136/bjsports-2015-094911) with interest. While we agree that discussion about the prevention and treatment of obesity is vital for scientific progress, we feel this article in its current state did not make a positive contribution to ongoing scientific debate....

    Show More
  • Inertia makes you hate work-cause or effect?
    Joseph Y Ting

    The most important ingredient for workplace satisfaction is meaningful engagement, which would liven our move and energy. Boredom and scarcity of challenge leads to inertia-mental and physical.

    Engagement enlivens flagging concentration,finds value and purpose in our desired vocation and offers sustained opportunities to sharpen focus on demanding tasks, which in turn boosts productivity and company profits....

    Show More
  • LCHF LIfestyle
    anton c kleinschmidt

    I have been on the LCHF lifestyle for about 18 months and have experienced huge improvements to my health. I am no longer obese, my blood pressure has normalised, my lipid and glucose profiles have improved, sleep apnoea has ceased, no more heartburn and energy levels have improved.

    This has all been possible using the guidance contained in the books of the two authors and also gary taubes, robert lustig and nin...

    Show More
  • The need to think twice before making a press release
    Francis Quinn

    I write as an academic health psychologist, whose main interest is changing behaviour toward healthier living. A BBC News article entitled "Exercise 'not key to obesity fight'" drew my attention to this editorial.

    On reading the full text, I discovered that the authors were mainly writing about the causes of obesity, rather than about change. No doubt the one controversial statement in the editorial (unsupporte...

    Show More