Table 2

Strength criteria used for return to running

Strength criteria (n (%))30 (15%)
Isometric test criteria (studies, n) 13 (6%)
 LSI>60%39 40 2 (1%)
 LSI>65%30 1
 LSI>70%26 28 54 (‘isometric leg press testing’)70 4 (3%)
 LSI>85%43 1 (0.5%)
 Quadriceps LSI>60%40 1 (0.5%)
 Quadriceps LSI>70%42 1 (0.5%)
 Quadriceps LSI>75%33 1 (0.5%)
 Quadriceps LSI>80%6 47 50 3 (2%)
Isotonic test criteria (studies, n) 2 (1%)
 LSI>50% (with ‘Push strength on the leg press’, n=1)39 1
 LSI>80% (‘1-repetition maximum on the leg press (90-0°)’, n=1)34 1
Isokinetic test criteria (studies, n) 13 (6%)
 Hamstrings:quadriceps ratio between 60% and 70%71 1
 Quadriceps LSI>80%, hamstrings LSI>110%, quadriceps torque/BW ratio >55%, hamstrings:quadriceps ratio >70%46 1
 Quadriceps and hamstrings LSI>65%30 45 72 3 (2%)
 Quadriceps and hamstring LSI>70%25 55 56 70 4 (2%)
 Quadriceps and hamstring LSI>75%24 1
 Quadriceps torque/BW ratio at 300°/s: (>40% (men) and >30% (women)) and quadriceps torque/BW ratio at 180°/s: (>60% (men) and >50% (women))5 1
  ‘…satisfactory isokinetic test…’59 62 2 (1%)
Other subjective or unclear criteria (studies, n) 6 (3%)
 ‘Good manual strength test’38 49
 ‘…Lift 15 lbs during short arc quadriceps exercise… ’71 1
 ‘Good muscle strength and control’ (…when muscle strength and control allow…)73 1
 ‘…Sufficient musculature…’74 1
 ‘…Good quadriceps contraction in extension…’41 1
  • BW, body weight; LSI, limb symmetry index.