Characteristics of the studies included in the systematic review and meta-analysis
Study, year | Design | Subjects: n, sex, age, years±SD or range | Fitness | Intervention | Outcomes |
Molphy et al, 201958 | Three-way cross-over | 16, M/F 8/8, 23±3 | Recreationally active >2 times/week | Inhaled terbutaline 2000 μg Inhaled terbutaline 4000 µg | 3000 m treadmill time trial |
Merlini et al, 201957 | Cross-over | 13, M, 18±1 | Amateur football | Inhaled salbutamol 1600 μg | Shuttle run test |
Hafedh et al, 201956 | Cross-over | 12, 6/6, 22±1 | Recreationally active | Oral terbutaline 8000 µg | Shuttle run test |
Laurent et al, 201855 | Three-way cross-over | 14, M, 25±5 | Endurance athletes 6±2 hours/week | Inhaled salbutamol 800 µg Oral salbutamol 4000 µg | Quadriceps contractions to task failure |
Eckerström et al, 201854 | Cross-over | 36, M/F 18/18, 26±5 | Non-athletes | Inhaled salbutamol 900 µg | VO2max |
Molphy et al, 201753 | Three-way cross-over | 7, M, 22±1 | Recreational exercise ≥3 hours/week | Inhaled salbutamol 400 µg | 3000 m treadmill time trial |
Halabchi et al, 201752 | Cross-over | 20, M, 17±1 | Junior professional football players | Inhaled 200 µg salbutamol | 20 m multistage shuttle run test |
Hostrup et al, 201662 | Parallel | 20, M, 26±4 | National level endurance athletes* | Oral salbutamol 8000 µg acute and 8000 µg/day for 2 weeks | VO2max, time to exhaustion |
Koch et al, 201551 | Cross-over | 35, M, 28±5 | Experienced cyclists/triathletes, VO2max
≥60 mL/kg/min or 5 L | Inhaled salbutamol 400 µg | 10 km ergometer time trial |
Koch et al, 201550 | Cross-over | 15, F, 30±5 | Cyclists and triathletes VO2max 50 mL/kg/min or 4 L | Inhaled salbutamol 400 µg | 10 km ergometer time trial |
Koch et al, 201549 | Cross-over | 12, M, 31±7 | Competitive cyclists VO2max ≥60 mL/kg/min or 5 L | Inhaled salbutamol 1600 μg | 10 km ergometer time trial |
Hostrup et al, 201561 | Parallel | 18, M, 24±3 | Recreationally active 4–8 hours/week | Oral terbutaline 5000 µg/30 kg body weight, two times per day for 28±1 days | VO2max, cycling to exhaustion, incremental |
Kalsen et al, 201448 | Cross-over | 9, M, 24±3 | Moderately trained | Inhaled terbutaline 15 000 µg | 300 kcal cycling time trial |
Hostrup et al, 201447 | Cross-over | 9, M, 24±3 | Recreationally active | Inhaled terbutaline 15 000 µg | 100 kcal cycling time trial |
Dickinson et al, 201460 | Parallel | 16, M, 20±2 | Amateur-level competition | Inhaled salbutamol 1600 µg/day for 6 weeks | V̇O2peak, 3 km treadmill time trial |
Dickinson et al, 201446 | Three-way cross-over | 7, M, 22±4 | Runners, >2 times/week | Inhaled salbutamol 800 µg and 1600 µg | 5 km treadmill time trial in 18°C and 30°C |
Sanchez et al, 201345 | Cross-over | 7, M, 29±6 | Competitive recreational athletes, 10 hours/week | Oral terbutaline 8000 µg | Cycling to exhaustion, VO2max |
Decorte et al, 201344 | Three-way cross-over | 11, M, 33±6 | Highly trained cyclists/triathletes/runners, 12±3 hours/week* | Inhaled salbutamol 200 µg and 800 µg | Quadriceps contractions to task failure |
Elers et al, 201243 | Cross-over | 9, M, 27±5 | Endurance-trained 11 hours/week* | Inhaled 8000 µg salbutamol | Peak power output, incremental VO2max |
Beloka et al, 201142 | Cross-over | 21, M, 23±2 | Healthy non-athletes | Infused salbutamol 350 µg or 700 µg | VO2max |
Andersen and Kanstrup, 200941 | Cross-over | 7, M, 25, 18–30 | Highly endurance-trained* | Oral salbutamol 4000 µg | Running to exhaustion, VO2max |
Sporer et al, 200840 | Four-way cross-over | 27, M, 29±6 | Competitive cyclists and triathletes* | Inhaled salbutamol 200 µg, 400 µg and 800 µg | 20 km cycling time trial |
Decorte et al, 200839 | Three-way cross-over | 10, M, 23±3 | Healthy non-athletes | Inhaled salbutamol 200 µg and 800 µg | Cycling to exhaustion, incremental, VO2max |
Tjørhom et al, 200738 | Cross-over | 23, M, 29±5 | Endurance athletes, VO2max 60.6 mL/kg/min | Inhaled formoterol 18 µg | Running to exhaustion at −20°C at 107% VO2max, VO2max |
Riiser et al, 200637 | Cross-over | 20, M, 29±4 | Endurance athletes, VO2max 61.1 mL/kg/min | Inhaled formoterol 18 µg | Running to exhaustion in hypobaric conditions at 107% VO2max, VO2max |
van Baak et al, 200436 | Cross-over | 16, M, 23±3 | Cyclists and triathletes, training 11±3 hours/week* | Inhaled 800 µg salbutamol | Cycling time trial |
Stewart et al, 200235 | Three-way cross-over | 10, M, 26, 20–30 | Highly trained athletes* | Inhaled formoterol 12 µg or inhaled salbutamol 400 µg | VO2max |
Collomp et al, 200234 | Cross-over | 8, M, 26±2 | Moderately trained | Oral salbutamol 6000 µg | 10 min cycling time trial |
Collomp et al, 200029 | Cross-over | 9, M, 25±1 | Moderately trained | Oral salbutamol 6000 µg | Cycling to exhaustion at 85% of VO2max |
Collomp et al, 200030 | Cross-over | 8, M, 23±3 | Recreational athletes, cycling/running 3–5 times/week | Oral salbutamol 12 000 µg/day for 3 weeks | Cycling to exhaustion at 85% of VO2max |
Goubault et al, 200133 | Three-way cross-over | 13, M, 23±2 | Competitive triathlete | Inhaled salbutamol 200 µg and 800 µg | Cycling to exhaustion at 85% of VO2max |
Carlsen et al, 200132 | Cross-over | 24, M, 25±3 | Competitive athletes* | Inhaled formoterol 9 µg | Running to exhaustion at 105% of VO2max
VO2max |
van Baak et al, 200031 | Cross-over | 16, M, 23±2 | Healthy non-athletes | Oral salbutamol 4000 µg | Cycling to exhaustion at 70% of VO2max |
Sue-Chu et al, 199928 | Cross-over | 8, M, 19–28 | Highly trained cross-country skiers* | Inhaled salmeterol 50 µg | Running to exhaustion at −15°C, incremental VO2max |
Sandsund et al, 199827 | Cross-over | 8, M, 25±4 | Highly trained cross-country skiers* | Aerosolised salbutamol 1200 µg | Running to exhaustion, incremental, VO2max |
Larsson et al, 199726 | Cross-over | 20, M, 24, 18–31 | Elite endurance athletes* | Inhaled terbutaline 3000 µg | Running to exhaustion, incremental, VO2max |
Carlsen et al, 199725 | Three-way cross-over | 18, M, 23±6 | Running >3 times/week | Inhaled salbutamol 800 µg Inhaled salmeterol 50 µg | Running until exhaustion, incremental, VO2max |
Norris et al, 199624 | Cross-over | 15, M, 25±4 | Highly trained cyclists | Inhaled 400 µg salbutamol | 20 km cycling time trial VO2max |
Heir and Stemshaug, 199523 | Cross-over | 17, M, 18–30 | Highly conditioned endurance athletes* | Aerosolised salbutamol 50 µg/kg | Running to exhaustion at 110% VO2max, VO2peak |
Unnithan et al, 199422 | Cross-over | 10, M, 10±1 | Healthy non-athletes | Inhaled terbutaline 500 µg | Total running time VO2peak |
Fleck et al, 199321 | Cross-over | 21, M, 24±5 | Elite cyclists | Inhaled salbutamol 360 µg | W-max VO2max |
Morton et al, 199220 | Cross-over | 17, M/F 16/1, 22±4 | High-performance runners* | Inhaled salbutamol 200 µg | Running to exhaustion, incremental VO2max |
Meeuwisse et al, 199219 | Cross-over | 7, M, 24±4 | Trained cyclists | Inhaled salbutamol 200 μ g | Endurance sprint time VO2max |
Violante et al, 198918 | Cross-over | 7, M, 34±8 | Sedentary non-athletes | Intravenous salbutamol 4 µg/kg followed by 3 µg/kg/hour | Walking to exhaustion, incremental |
Bedi et al, 198816 | Cross-over | 15, M/F 14/1, 23±5 | Cyclists, triathletes | Inhaled salbutamol 180 µg | Cycling to exhaustion after 60 min submaximal exercise VO2max |
Booth, 198817 | Cross-over | 10, F, 21±7 | Trained cyclists | Inhaled salbutamol ×2, therapeutic dose | Cycling to exhaustion |
McKenzie et al, 198359 | Parallel | 4, M, 25±8 5, F, 27±10 5, M, 24±9 5, F, 26±13 | Highly trained track and field athletes* | Inhaled salbutamol 800 µg | VO2max |
*Denotes high-performance endurance athletes.
F, female; M, male; VO2max, Maximal oxygen consumption; W-max, maximal workload during incremental cycling.