Classification systems—abbreviated from online supplemental material
Based on | Author | G0 | G1 | GII | GIII | GIV |
Clinical Signs | Odonoghue | No appreciable tissue tear | Tissue damage and reduced strength of the muscle tendon unit | Complete tear of the muscle tendon unit and complete loss of function | ||
Ryan | Tear of a very small number of fibres with Fascia remaining intact | Tear of a higher no of fibres, fascia still remains intact | Greater number of muscle fibres involved. The muscular fascia is at least partially torn | Completed tear of the muscle belly and fascia rupture | ||
Wise | Min pain to palpation, localised | Substantial TOP, poorly localised, 6–12 mm change in circumference, develops 12–24 hours <50% loss of ROM, pain on contraction, loss of power, disturbed gait | Intractable TOP, diffuse, develops in 1 hour, >50% loss ROM, severe pain on contraction, almost complete loss of power, unable to WB | |||
Rachun | Localised pain, min swelling, bruising, minor disability | Local pain+TOP, moderate bruising+disability, stretching tearing fibres without disruption | Severe pain+swelling disability, severe haematoma, loss of function, palpable defect | |||
Imaging | Takebyashi | No abnormalities or diffuse bleeding with or without local fibre rupture (less than 5% of the muscle involved) | Focal fibre rupture—more than 5% of the muscle involved, with or without fascial injury | Complete muscle rupture with retraction, fascial injury is present | ||
Peetrons | lack of US lesion | Minimal elongation with less than 5% of muscle involved—hypoechoic area | Lesions involving from 5% to 50% of the muscle volume or cross-sectional diameter | Complete muscle tears with complete retraction | ||
Lee | Normal or focal/general areas of increased echogenicity—perifascial fluid | Discontinuity of muscle fibres in echogenic perimysal strae. Hypervascularity around disrupted muscle fibres. Intramuscular fluid collection, partial detachment of adjacent fascia or aponeurosis | Complete myotendinous or tendon-osseous avulsion, complete discontinuity of muscle fibres and associated haematoma. Bell clapper sign | |||
Chan (ISmULT) | Normal appearance. Focal or general increased echogenicity with no architectural distortion | Discontinuous muscle fibres. Disruption site is hyper-vasculised and altered in echogenicity. No perimysal striation adjacent to the MTJ | Complete discontinuity of muscle fibres. Haematoma and retraction of the muscle ends | Proximal MTJ/muscle proximal/ middle distal/ distal MTJ+intramuscular - myotendionous | ||
Schneider- Kolsky | <10° ROM deficit | 10°–25° ROM deficit | >25% ROM deficit | |||
Stoller | Hyperintense oedema+/-haemorrhage with preservation of the muscle morphology. Oedema pattern=interstitial hyperintensity and feathery distribution on FSPD or T2FSE+STIR images hyperintense subcutaneous tissue oedema+intermuscular fluid | Hyperintense haemorrhage with tearing of up to 50% of muscle fibres. Interstitial hyperintensity with focal hyperintensity representing haemorrhage in the muscle belly+/-intramuscular fluid. Hyperintense focal defect+partial retraction of muscle fibres. associated myotendinous+tendinous injuries. Hyperintensity+interruption +/- widening of muscle - tendon Unit | Complete tearing+/-muscle retraction. Hyperintense fluid filled gap+hyperintense on FSPDFSE+STIR. Associated adjacent hyperintense interstitial muscle changes | |||
Mixed | Cohen | Point grading score - Age/muscles/location/ cross sectional area/retraction/ longitudinal axis T2 signal length | ||||
Munich | Indirect | Functional muscle disorder (consider neuromeningeal) - negative imaging findings | ||||
Structural muscle injury: Grading on US/MRI classification System | ||||||
Direct muscle injury | ||||||
BAMIC | Negative imaging findings | <10% cross sectional area | 10%–50% cross sectional areas—5–15 cm | >50% cross sectional area >15 xm (tendon >5 cm) | Complete rupture | |
A -Myofascial tear (4 grades) incorporating cranio-caudal length and cross-sectional area for grading—small/moderate/extensive/complete | ||||||
B - Muscle Tendon Junction tear (4 grades) incorporating cranio-caudal length and cross-sectional area for grading | ||||||
C -Intra-tendinous tear (3–4 grades) incorporating cranio-caudal length and cross-sectional area for grading | ||||||
Barcelona - (MLG-R) mechanism of injury/location - muscle/grade/previous injury | Negative MRI but clinical suspicion | Hyperintense muscle fibre oedema without intramuscular haemorrhage or architectural distortion (fibre architecture and pennation angle preserved). Oedema pattern: interstitial hyperintensity with feathery distribution on FSPD or T2 FSE? STIR images | Hyperintense muscle fibre and/or peritendon oedema with minor muscle fibre architectural distortion (fibre blurring and/or pennation angle distortion) ± minor intermuscular haemorrhage, but no quantifiable gap between fibres. Oedema pattern, same as for grade 1 | Any quantifiable gap between fibres in craniocaudal or axial planes. Hyperintense focal defect with partial retraction of muscle fibres±intermuscular haemorrhage. The gap between fibres at the injury’s maximal area in an axial plane of the affected muscle belly should be documented. The exact % CSA should be documented as a subindex to the grade | ||
Mechanism of injury | Direct/indirect/stretch or sprint | |||||
Location | Location of lesion—proximal/middle/Distal | |||||
Extracellular matrix | When codifying an intratendon injury or an injury affecting the MTJ or intramuscular tendon showing disruption/retraction or loss of tension exist (gap), a superscript (r) should be added to the grade | |||||
Surgical | Wood | Proximal hamstring attachment rupture based on | MTJ versus Tendon injury/avulsion—bony versus tendon/avulsion—partial versus complete/ retraction distance/ sciatic nerve involvement | |||
Lampainen | No of tendons involved (1–3)/level of athlete(demand)/level of symptoms (pain+function) |
BAMIC, British Athletics Muscle Injury Classification; CSA, cross-sectional area; FSE, fast spin echo; FSPD, fat-suppressed proton density; MTJ, musculotendinous junction; ROM, range of motion; STIR, short tau inversion recovery; TOP, tender on palpation; US, ultrasound.