Table 2

Definition of consensus

CategoryDefinitionAction
Consensus in (high agreement)Scored as very important (7–9) by ≥70% of panel members and not important (1–3) by <15% of panel membersItem retained for the next survey round/consensus meeting.
Consensus out (low agreement)Scored as not important (1–3) by ≥70% of panel members and very important (7–9) by <15% of panel membersItem discarded after round 2 (to be ratified at the face-to-face consensus meeting).
No consensusNeither criteria above are metItem retained for the next survey round/consensus meeting.
Suggest rewordingScored as important but must be reworded.Provide the opportunity for panel members to suggest rewording. The study steering committee will consider retaining a reworded item for the next survey round.