Incidence studies in the military and general population
Author | Year | Country | Study design | Case identification | Denominator | Exertional deaths of all? | SCD or SCA+SCD | Years studied | Population | Incidence | No. of years | Age range | Mean age | No. of cardiac deaths |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Eckart44 | 2004 | USA | Retrospective cohort | Mandatory reporting of all deaths to DOD recruit mortality registry with autopsy data | Numbers from DOD | All | SCD | 1977–2001 | Military recruits | 1:10 000 | 25 | 18–35 | 19 | 108 |
Gunnarson36 | 2006 | Iceland | Retrospective cohort | Death certificates and autopsy reports reviewed | Iceland population statistics | All | SCD | 1974–2004 | Young people | 1:68 000 | 30 | 12–35 | 45 | |
Atkins41 | 2009 | USA and Canada | Prospective cohort study | EMS responding to confirmed cardiac cases | Population statistics | All | SCA+SCD | 2005–2007 | Young people | 1:49 000 | 3 | 12–19 | 16.4 | 193 |
Chugh42 | 2009 | USA | Prospective population based | EMS responding to confirmed cardiac cases | Population statistics | All | SCA+SCD | 2002–2005 | Young people | 1:58 828 | 3 | 10–14 | _ | 2 |
Papdakis37 | 2009 | UK | Retrospective cohort | Review of death certificates | Population statistics | All | 2002–2005 | Young people | 1:55 000 | 4 | 1–34 | _ | 3409 | |
Holst6 | 2010 | Denmark | Retrospect cohort | Death certificates and autopsy reports reviewed if available (67%) | Population statistics | All | SCD | 2000–2006 | Young people | 1:35 000 | 7 | 1–35 | 26.4 | 15 |
Solberg14 | 2010 | Norway | Retrospective cohort | Norwegian cause of death registry—validated with autopsy and medical records | Population statistics | Exertional | SCD | 1979–1998 | Young people | 1:111 111 | 20 | 15–34 | 27 | 23 |
Cooper40 | 2011 | USA | Retrospective cohort | Automated data from 4 health plans—study carried out to compare ADHD users to non-users | Number of those 2–24 in health plan | All | SCA+SCD | 1986–2005 | Young people | 1:32 258 | 19 | 2–24 | 11.1 | 81 |
Eckart12 | 2011 | USA | Retrospective cohort | Mandatory reporting of all deaths to DOD mortality registry with autopsy data | DOD statistics | All | SCD | 1998–2008 | Military | <20–1:2 967 320–24 1:4 098 325–29–1:3 012 030–35–1:25 000 | 10 | 18–34 | _ | 298 |
Margey39 | 2011 | Ireland | Retrospective cohort | Death certificate review with autopsy confirmation | Population statistics | All | SCD | 2005–2007 | Young people | 1:350 001:20 000 males 1:77 000 female | 3 | 15–35 | 25 | 116 |
Marjion13 | 2011 | France | Prospective | EMS responding to confirmed cardiac cases | Population statistics | Sports related | SCA+SCD | 2005–2010 | Young people | 1:102 000 competitive athletes (10–35) | 5 | 12–75 | 46 | 820 |
Meyer43 | 2012 | USA | Prospective population based | EMS responding to confirmed cardiac cases | Population statistics | All | SCA+SCD | 1980–2009 | Young people | 14–24 1:69.00 025 –35 1:22 700 | 30 | 14–24 25–35 | _ | 14–24: 60 25–35: 245 |
Pilmer10 | 2013 | Ontario, Canada | Retrospective cohort | From coroner’s database | Population statistics | All | SCD | 2008 | Young people | 1:34 000 (19–29) | 1 | 2–40 | _ | 174 |
Pilmer38 | 2014 | Ontario, Canada | Retrospective cohort | From coroner’s database | Population statistics | All | SCD | 2005–2009 | Young people | 1:128 000 | 5 | 1–19 | 12 | 116 |
Winkle33 | 2014 | Denmark | Retrospective cohort | Death certificates, autopsy reports and health records reviewed | Population statistics | All | SCD | 2000–2006 | Young people | 1:90 909 | 7 | 1–18 | 13 | 62 |
SCA, sudden cardiac arrest; SCD, sudden cardiac death.