Table 1

Description of included studies in the systematic review

AuthorsName of questionnaireClinimetric evaluation(s)Time of administrationTarget populationStudy population
Christensen et al31NAHSContent validity
Internal consistency
Construct validity
Test–retest reliability
Clinical visitYoung patients with hip pain preoperative and postoperativeN=48/17
29/11 ♀, 19/6 ♂
Mean 33/32 years
Range (16–45 years)
Castillo et al37NAHSInternal consistency
Construct validity
Floor and ceiling effects
Test–retest reliability
Agreement
Clinical visitYoung patients with articular and musculoskeletal hip pain preoperative and postoperativeN=64
31 ♀, 33 ♂
Mean (SD) 40.9 (24.8) years
Range (18–76 years)
Griffin et al38IHOT-12Content validity
Construct validity
Test–retest reliability
Responsiveness
Clinical visit/postoperativeYoung active patients with articular and musculoskeletal hip diseaseN=104/1833/80
48/821/42 ♀, 56/1012/38 ♂
Mean 36.5/39.3/38.1 years
Henkus et al39SUSHIContent validity
Construct validity
Floor and ceiling effects
Responsiveness
Preoperative/postoperativeYoung patients with articular hip pathologyN=100
32 ♀, 68 ♂
Mean (SD) 44.9 (9.8) years
Hinman et al40HAGOS, HOOS, HOS, IHOT-33, mHHS, NAHSTest–retest reliability
Agreement
Responsiveness
Clinical visitYoung active patients with hip/groin pain (FAI)N=30
15 ♀, 15 ♂
Mean (SD) 24 (4) years
Range (18–30 years)
Jónasson et al41IHOT-12Internal consistency
Construct validity
Floor and ceiling effects
Test–retest reliability
Agreement
Responsiveness
Interpretability
Preoperative/postoperativePatients with hip pain preoperative and postoperative (FAI)N=502
165 ♀, 337 ♂
Mean (SD) 37 (13.4) years
Range (15–75 years)
Kemp et al11HAGOS, HOOS, HOS, IHOT-33, mHHSInternal consistency
Construct validity
Floor and ceiling effects
Test–retest reliability
Agreement
Responsiveness
Interpretability
PostoperativeHip arthroscopy
(Labral tear/FAI/chondropathy)
N=50
26 ♀, 24 ♂
Mean (SD) 37.4 (11.3) years
Range (18–57 years)
Lee et al42HOSInternal consistency
Construct validity
Floor and ceiling effects
Test–retest reliability
Responsiveness
Interpretability
Preoperative/postoperativeHip arthroscopy
(Labral tear/FAI/snapping hip)
N=60
26 ♀, 34 ♂
Mean 38.4 years
Range (16–80 years)
Martin et al32HOSContent validity
Internal consistency
Construct validity
Clinical visit/postoperativeHip arthroscopy (labral tear)N=507
273 ♀, 232 ♂
Mean (SD) 38 (13) years
Range (13–66 years)
Martin et al33HOSConstruct validityPostoperativeHip arthroscopyN=107
56 ♀, 51 ♂
Mean (SD) 42 (14) years
Range (14–79) years
Martin et al34HOSTest–retest reliability
Agreement
Responsiveness
Interpretability
Preoperative/postoperativeHip arthroscopy
(Labral tear/FAI/chondral lesions/capsular laxity)
N=126
59 ♀, 67 ♂
Mean (SD) 41 (16) years
Range (13–80) years
Mohtadi et al12IHOT-33Content validity
Internal consistency
Construct validity
Floor and ceiling effects
Test–retest reliability
Responsiveness
Clinical visit/preoperative/ postoperativeYoung active patients with articular and musculoskeletal hip pathologyN=433
234 ♀, 196 ♂, 3 unknown
Mean (SD) 40 years
Range (18–60 years)
Naal et al43HOSInternal consistency
Construct validity
Floor and ceiling effects
Test–retest reliability
Responsiveness
Preoperative/postoperativeHip arthroscopy/surgical dislocation (FAI)N=85
36 ♀, 49 ♂
Mean (SD) 33 (12) years
Naal et al44HSASContent validity
Construct validity
Floor and ceiling effects
Test–retest reliability
Responsiveness
Preoperative/postoperativeHip arthroscopy (FAI)N=30/29
7/12 ♀, 21/17 ♂
Mean (SD) 25.6/32.5 (8/8.8) years
Polesello et al45IHOT-33, IHOT-12Clinical visitYoung patients with hip painN=30
Mean (SD) <40 years
Potter et al35mHHSConstruct validity
Interpretability
PostoperativeHip arthroscopy (labral tear)N=33
19 ♀, 14 ♂
Mean 34.6 years
Range (21–56 years)
Rothenfluh et al36WOMAC-12Internal consistencyClinical visitFAIN=100
55 ♀, 45 ♂
Mean (SD) 31.7 (9.7) years
Range (13–42 years)
Seijas et al46HOSInternal consistency
Construct validity
Floor and ceiling effects
Test–retest reliability
Agreement
Responsiveness
Preoperative/postoperativeYoung patients with symptomatic articular hip pathologyN=100
36 ♀, 64 ♂
Mean (SD) 41.5 (12.1) years
Range (18–65 years)
Thomeé et al47HAGOSInternal consistency
Construct validity
Floor and ceiling effects
Test–retest reliability
Agreement
Responsiveness
Interpretability
Preoperative/postoperativePatients with hip pain preoperative and postoperative (FAI)N=502
165 ♀, 337 ♂
Mean (SD) 37 (13.4) years
Range (15–75 years)
Thorborg et al14HAGOSContent validity
Internal consistency
Construct validity
Floor and ceiling effects
Test–retest reliability
Agreement
Responsiveness
Interpretability
Clinical visitPatients with articular and musculoskeletal hip/groin painN=101
50 ♀, 51 ♂
Mean (SD) 36 (11) years
Range (18–63 years)
  • / Indicates different subgroups with data of each subgroup provided were used to investigate the questionnaire. Data from these subgroups are split by /. ♀ Indicates female and ♂ indicates male.

  • FAI, femoroacetabular impingement; HAGOS, Hip And Groin Outcome Score; HOOS, Hip disability and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score; HOS, Hip Outcome Score; HSAS, Hip Sports Activity Scale; IHOT, International Hip Outcome Tool; mHHS, modified Harris Hip Score; NAHS, Non-Arthritic Hip Score; SUSHI, Super Simple Hip Score; WOMAC-12, Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis index-12.