Prevalence of overuse wrist injuries and wrist pain
Study information | Study population | Outcomes | Prevalence rates | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Author (year), country | Design | Data collection | Sample size (F, M) | Mean age in years (SD and/or range) | Type and level of sport | Overuse wrist injury definition and period of measurement | Results | Wrist pain | Overuse wrist injuries | Quality level |
Chang et al14 (1995), Taiwan | Cross-sectional | Questionnaire | 261 (143 F, 118 M) | 14.4 (SD 2.4) (range 10–19) | Chinese opera actors and traditional performers | Wrist pain (period not specified) | 174 participants with WP 76 participants with bilateral WP (29%) | 66.7%† | – | Good |
Kirby et al15 (1981), Canada | Cross-sectional | Interview with participant, musculoskeletal examination, information from parents or coaches | 59 (all F) | 11.8 (SD 2.5) | Gymnastics: competitive level, at time of provincial championships | Any musculoskeletal symptoms of the wrist (period not specified) | 20 participants with right WP 19 participants with left WP | Right WP 33.9%* Left WP 32.2%* | – | Low |
DiFiori et al16 (1996), USA | Cross-sectional | Survey‡ | 52 (32 F, 20 M) | 11.8 (no SD) Gender subgroups: F, 12.3 (SD 2.0); M, 10.9 (SD 3.3) | Gymnastics, of elite (0), advanced (3), middle (12), and beginning (17) levels | Wrist pain within 6 months previous to survey WP grades: grade 1 (unrestricted), grade 2 (attends all training sessions, but unable to do full workout), grade 3 (misses at least one training session per month), grade 4 (unable to participate) | 38 participants with WP grade 1–4 (28 F, 10 M) WP distribution: grade 1 (14), grade 2 (16), grade 3 (8), grade 4 (0) 27 participants with bilateral WP (52%) 18 participants with WP >6 months | 73%† | – | Sufficient |
DiFiori et al17 (2002), USA | Cross-sectional | Questionnaire, physical examination, radiographs | 59 (28 F, 31 M) | 9.3 (SD 2.4) Gender subgroups: F, 9.4 (SD 2.5); M, 9.3 (SD 2.3) | Gymnastics, of precompetitive (26), beginning (26), middle (5), advanced (2), and elite (0) levels | Wrist pain within 6 months previous to survey WP quantified by whether symptoms limited the extent of training or how many days of training were missed per month | 33 participants with WP (17 F (61%), 16 M (52%)) 22 participants with bilateral WP 15 participants with WP >6 months 12 participants with symptoms interfering with training | 56%† | – | Good |
Dixon and Fricker18 (1993), Australia | Retrospective cohort | Reviewing of medical records of gymnasts at sports medicine department, where all medical complaints of the institute's gymnasts are attended to | 116 (74 F, 42 M) | Not specified Gender subgroups: F, 13.5 (range 9–19); M, 16.5 (range 12–22) | Gymnastics in program oriented towards elite competitors | Chronic wrist injury presented to sports medicine department within 10 years previous to data collection, persisting over a longer period of time and sustained while training or competing, either resulting from initial acute event or from repetitive subthreshold forces (overuse) | 33 participants with chronic wrist injury 13 F (5 right, 5 left, 3 bilateral) 20 M (8 right, 7 left, 5 bilateral) Most frequent in F: ligament sprain/tendonitis (5), impingement syndrome (8), epiphysial stress (3) Most frequent in M: impingement syndrome (23), ligament strains (3) Stress fracture: 3 (all M) | – | 28.4%† | Good |
Purnell et al19 (2010), Australia | Cross-sectional | Questionnaire§ | 73 (69 F, 4 M) | Not specified Gender subgroups: F, 13.4 (SD 3.6); M, 20.5 (SD 4.2) | Acrobatic gymnastics, recreational and competitive | Chronic injury to wrist that currently affects training or performance and has given continuing problems for 3 months or more | 7 current chronic wrist injuries | – | 9.6%† | Sufficient |
*The total number of patients with bilateral wrist pain was not reported.
†Prevalence calculated from published data.
‡Type of survey (eg, written questionnaire or interview) not specified.
§Primary school aged participants completed questionnaire with parental assistance.
F, female; M, male; WP, wrist pain.