Heart rate responses to deep breathing and 4-seconds of exercise before and after pharmacological blockade with atropine and propranolol

Abstract

Two autonomic tests which evaluate cardiac vagal activity, the respiratory sinus arrhythmia and the newer 4-second exercise test, have been compared. From electrocardiograph tracings, respiratory sinus arrhythmia was quantified by the ratio between the longest R-R interval during expiration and the shortest one during inspiration (E/I ratio), and the 4-second exercise test by the ratio between the last R-R interval before and the shortest one during exercise (B/C ratio). In 29 healthy subjects there was a correlation (R = 0.60,p < 0.05) between the responses to the two tests. In a group of six healthy subjects the same tests were performed after autonomic blockade with intravenous atropine and/or propranolol. The heart rate rise during the 4-second exercise test was nearly abolished by atropine (mean ± SD) (B/C: control = 1.53/0.33; after atropine = 1.04/0.03), whereas RSA was diminished to a lesser extent (E/I: control = 1.59/0.24; after atropine = 1.13/0.07). β-adrenoceptor blockade did not affect the test ratios (after propranolol: B/C = 1.51/0.33 and E/I = 1.45/0.14). Successive tests during the following hour after atropine infusion showed a somewhat faster recovery of the respiratory sinus arrhythmia than the heart rate acceleration induced by the 4-second exercise test (p < 0.05). We conclude that there may be some difference in the mechanisms which contribute to the heart rate changes in these two autonomic cardiovascular tests; these remain to be clarified. The 4-second exercise test may be an alternative to the respiratory sinus arrhythmia test in the non-invasive evaluation of cardiac parasympathetic activity.