Elsevier

Physiotherapy

Volume 100, Issue 3, September 2014, Pages 220-227
Physiotherapy

Systematic review
The effectiveness of therapeutic exercise for joint hypermobility syndrome: a systematic review

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physio.2013.09.002Get rights and content

Abstract

Background

Joint hypermobility syndrome (JHS) is a heritable connective tissue disorder characterised by excessive range of movement at multiple joints accompanied by pain. Exercise is the mainstay of management yet its effectiveness is unclear.

Objectives

To establish the effectiveness of therapeutic exercise for JHS.

Data sources

A search of nine online databases, supplemented by a hand search and snowballing.

Study eligibility criteria (participants and interventions)

People diagnosed with JHS (rather than asymptomatic generalised joint laxity); therapeutic exercise (of any type) used as an intervention; primary data reported; English language; published research.

Study appraisal and synthesis methods

Methodological quality was appraised by each reviewer using Critical Appraisal Skills Programme checklists. Articles were then discussed collectively and disagreements resolved through debate.

Results

2001 titles were identified. Four articles met the inclusion criteria, comprising one controlled trial, one comparative trial and two cohort studies. All studies found clinical improvements over time. However there was no convincing evidence that exercise was better than control or that joint-specific and generalised exercise differed in effectiveness.

Limitations

The studies used heterogeneous outcome measures, preventing pooling of results. Only one study was a true controlled trial which failed to report between-group statistical analyses post-treatment.

Conclusions and implications of key findings

There is some evidence that people with JHS improve with exercise but there is no convincing evidence for specific types of exercise or that exercise is better than control. Further high quality research is required to establish the effectiveness of exercise for JHS.

Introduction

Joint hypermobility syndrome (JHS) has been defined as a “heritable disorder of the connective tissues characterised by hypermobility, often affecting multiple joints, and musculoskeletal pains in the absence of systemic inflammatory joint disease such as rheumatoid arthritis” [1]. Variation in diagnostic criteria makes interpretation of published literature difficult but the revised Brighton Criteria [2] are now widely used. JHS is generally accepted to be more prevalent in children, in females and in some ethnic groups. Approximately 5% of women and less than 1% of men experience symptomatic joint hypermobility [3].

Joint pain in JHS is thought to be caused by excessive movement increasing stress on joint surfaces, ligaments and neighbouring structures [3]. Pain may cause muscle inhibition, leading to atrophy and reduced joint control [4]. Proprioceptive acuity may also be adversely affected [5], [6], perhaps due to joint mechanoreceptor damage [7]. The inability to acknowledge extreme joint ranges may create an even more unstable joint by further stretching supporting structures. JHS can be accompanied by fatigue [8], anxiety and depression, impacting negatively on social function [9] and thereby having a substantial impact on individuals.

Acute pain episodes may be managed using taping, bracing or splinting [4] or with non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs [3]. However education [10], [11] and therapeutic exercise [12] are the mainstays of long term management. Encouraging an active lifestyle may improve function and enhance quality of life [13].

Strengthening exercises targeting stabilising muscles around hypermobile joints might enhance joint support throughout movement and reduce pain [14], [15]. Closed chain exercises may reduce strain on injured ligaments [16], enhance proprioceptive feedback [4], and optimise muscle action [17]. Coordination and balance exercises such as wobble board training may improve proprioception [18], [19]. Neural pathways and movement patterns consisting of muscle pair co-contractions are reinforced [20]. This can encourage compensation reactions [21], preventing joints moving into extreme ranges and avoiding further injury [3].

In contrast to specific muscle training, a generalised exercise approach can also be taken, addressing cardio-respiratory, musculoskeletal and neurological aspects of movement [22] and reducing general deconditioning [23]. Hydrotherapy can be a successful medium in which to perform such exercises [22], challenging balance and core strength within a supportive environment, with water resistance and buoyancy increasing exercise variability [24].

Although exercise is widely regarded as a core component of JHS management [4], [12], there is no clear consensus about its effectiveness. There is generally a lack of high quality research which might contribute to the prescription of inappropriate interventions [25] and negative experiences of physiotherapy [1]. It is timely that the available evidence for exercise should be systematically evaluated.

This systematic review aimed to establish the effectiveness of therapeutic exercise for JHS. Due to the small number of studies identified in initial scoping work, it was decided not to prescribe the specific type of exercise or the clinical outcomes.

Section snippets

Methods

This review has been reported in accordance with PRISMA recommendations [26].

Study selection

The process of study selection is summarised in Supplemental Information, Figure A. After duplicates were removed a total of 2001 potentially relevant articles were identified (1967 from the electronic search, two from the hand search and 32 from snowballing). Successive application of the inclusion criteria to the titles, abstracts and full texts left four articles for inclusion within the review (three from the electronic and hand search and one from snowballing).

Study characteristics

Table 1 provides a synopsis

Summary of evidence

This review identified one randomised comparative trial in children [29], and one randomised controlled trial [30] and two cohort studies in adults [1], [31]. The evidence suggests that people with JHS who undertake exercise improve over time in a range of patient (and parent) reported outcomes (including pain, global assessment of the impact of hypermobility, maximum distance walked and quality of life) and objective outcomes (including proprioception, balance, strength and range of movement).

Conclusions

Overall, the available evidence suggests that patients who received an exercise intervention improved over time and no adverse effects were reported. However, there was no convincing evidence that generalised exercise was any better than joint-specific exercise [29] or that knee exercises were any better than a control condition [30]. Clear cause-effect relationships for exercise have therefore not been demonstrated. The methodological quality of the included studies was generally lacking,

References (34)

  • A.J. Hakim et al.

    Non-musculoskeletal symptoms in joint hypermobility syndrome. Indirect evidence for autonomic dysfunction?

    Rheumatology

    (2004)
  • J.F. Bravo et al.

    Neuromuscular physiology in joint hypermobility

  • L.N. Russek

    Joint hypermobility

    Phys Ther

    (1999)
  • L.N. Russek

    Examination and treatment of a patient with hypermobility syndrome

    Phys Ther

    (2000)
  • J.E. Graves et al.

    Specificity of limited range of motion variable resistance training

    Med Sci Sports Exerc

    (1989)
  • T.A. Kitai et al.

    Specificity of joint angle in isometric training

    Eur J Appl Physiol

    (1989)
  • G.K. Fitzgerald

    Open versus closed kinetic chain exercise: issues in rehabilitation after anterior cruciate ligament reconstructive surgery

    Phys Ther

    (1997)
  • Cited by (55)

    • Upslope walking increases anterior tibial translation deficiency in patients with generalized joint hypermobility

      2022, Gait and Posture
      Citation Excerpt :

      GJH is a lifetime disease that may increase the odds of prevalence of knee injuries and KOA [6–8]. Life-time therapeutic monitoring and management are essential for patients with GJH and have been promoted by scholars and clinicians[43–46]. During GJH patients’ long-term therapy strategy or management, scholars and clinicians can use upslope walking motion tasks to reveal or monitor tibial anterior translation deficiency effectively.

    • Exercise and Rehabilitation in People With Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome: A Systematic Review

      2022, Archives of Rehabilitation Research and Clinical Translation
    • A qualitative evaluation of the appropriateness, validity, acceptability, feasibility and interpretability of the Bristol Impact of Hypermobility (BIoH) questionnaire

      2018, Musculoskeletal Science and Practice
      Citation Excerpt :

      Physiotherapy is the main treatment for JHS, particularly exercise to enhance physical function. Two systematic reviews have, however, highlighted a lack of evidence to support therapy (Palmer et al., 2014; Smith et al., 2014a). A lack of congruence between the aims of physiotherapy and the outcome measures used to evaluate effectiveness has also been identified (Palmer et al., 2015).

    • The Pilates client on the hypermobility spectrum

      2018, Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies
    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text