Abstract
Preparticipation screening for unsuspected cardiovascular disease is a controversial topic in the medical and lay communities. Much attention has been directed towards young competitive athletes, particularly the proposed strategy of incorporating 12-lead electrocardiograms into the screening process, even on a national or worldwide basis. However, sudden deaths of young athletes owing to genetic or congenital heart diseases have a low incidence in the general population. Furthermore, young people not engaged in competitive sports can harbour the same conditions that cause sudden death in athletes, which has gone largely unrecognized. Notably, sudden deaths from these diseases are numerically far more common in the much larger population of nonathletes. In this Perspectives article, we propose that an ethical dilemma has emerged, raising the important public-health issue of whether young individuals should be arbitrarily excluded from potentially life-saving clinical screening evaluations because they do not engage in competitive sports programmes.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution
Access options
Subscribe to this journal
Receive 12 print issues and online access
$209.00 per year
only $17.42 per issue
Rent or buy this article
Prices vary by article type
from$1.95
to$39.95
Prices may be subject to local taxes which are calculated during checkout
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Maron, B. J. Sudden death in young athletes. N. Engl. J. Med. 349, 1064–1075 (2003).
Maron, B. J., Doerer, J. J., Haas, T. S., Tierney, D. M. & Mueller, F. O. Sudden deaths in young competitive athletes: analysis of 1866 deaths in the United States, 1980–2006. Circulation 119, 1085–1092 (2009).
Maron, B. J., et al. Sudden death in young competitive athletes: clinical, demographic, and pathological profiles. JAMA 276, 199–204 (1996).
Maron, B. J., Haas, T. S., Ahluwalia, A. & Rutten-Ramos, S. C. Incidence of cardiovascular deaths in Minnesota high school athletes. Heart Rhythm 10, 374–377 (2013).
Corrado, D. et al. Trends in sudden cardiovascular death in young competitive athletes after implementation of a preparticipation screening program. JAMA 296, 1593–1601 (2006).
Maron, B. J. et al. Assessment of the 12-lead electrocardiogram as a screening test for detection of cardiovascular disease in general healthy populations of young people (12–25 years of age). J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 64, 1479–1514 (2014).
Maron, B. J., Haas, T. H., Murphy, C. J., Ahluwalia, A. & Rutten-Ramos, S. Incidence and causes of sudden death in U.S. college athletes. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 63, 1636–1643 (2014).
Maron, B. J. & Estes, N. A. 3rd. Commotio cordis. N. Engl. J. Med. 362, 917–927 (2010).
Maron, B. J., Roberts, W. C., McAllister, H. A., Rosing, D. R. & Epstein, S. E. Sudden death in young athletes. Circulation 62, 218–229 (1980).
Corrado, D. et al. Cardiovascular pre-participation screening of young competitive athletes for prevention of sudden death: proposal for a common European protocol. Consensus Statement of the Study Group of Sport Cardiology of the Working Group of Cardiac Rehabilitation and Exercise Physiology and the Working Group of Myocardial and Pericardial Diseases of the European Society of Cardiology. Eur. Heart J. 26, 516–524 (2005).
Baggish, A. L. et al. Cardiovascular screening in college athletes with and without electrocardiography: a cross-sectional study. Ann. Intern. Med. 152, 269–275 (2010).
Glover, D. W. & Maron, B. J. Profile of preparticipation cardiovascular screening for high school athletes. JAMA 279, 1817–1819 (1998).
Corrado, D., Basso, C., Schiavon, M. & Thiene, G. Screening for hypertrophic cardiomyopathy in young athletes. N. Engl. J. Med. 339, 364–369 (1998).
Pfister, G. C., Puffer, J. C. & Maron, B. J. Preparticipation cardiovascular screening for US collegiate student-athletes. JAMA 283, 1597–1599 (2000).
Myerburg, R. J. & Vetter, V. L. Electrocardiograms should be included in preparticipation screening of athletes. Circulation 116, 2616–2626 (2007).
Drezner, J. A. ECG screening in athletes: time to develop infrastructure. Heart Rhythm 8, 1560–1561 (2011).
Corrado, D. & Thiene, G. Protagonist: routine screening of all athletes prior to participation in competitive sports should be mandatory to prevent sudden cardiac death. Heart Rhythm 4, 520–524 (2007).
Thiene, G., Corrado, D., Schiavon, M. & Basso, C. Screening of competitive athletes to prevent sudden death: implement programmes now. Heart 99, 304–306 (2013).
Corrado, D., Basso, C., Schiavon, M., Pelliccia, A. & Thiene, G. Pre-participation screening of young competitive athletes for prevention of sudden cardiac death. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 52, 1981–1989 (2008).
Chaitman, B. R. An electrocardiogram should not be included in routine preparticipation screening of young athletes. Circulation 116, 2610–2614 (2007).
Estes, N. A. 3rd & Link, M. S. Preparticipation athletic screening including an electrocardiogram: an unproven strategy for prevention of sudden cardiac death in the athlete. Prog. Cardiovasc. Dis. 54, 451–454 (2012).
Viskin, S. Antagonist: routine screening of all athletes prior to participation in competitive sports should be mandatory to prevent sudden cardiac death. Heart Rhythm 4, 525–528 (2007).
Thompson, P. D. Preparticipation screening of competitive athletes: seeking simple solutions to a complex problem. Circulation 119, 1072–1074 (2009).
Maron, B. J. Counterpoint: mandatory ECG screening of young competitive athletes. Heart Rhythm 9, 1646–1649 (2012).
Steinvil, A. et al. Mandatory electrocardiographic screening of athletes to reduce their risk for sudden death proven fact or wishful thinking? J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 57, 1291–1296 (2011).
Kerr, Z. Y. et al. Impact locations and concussion outcomes in high school football player-to-player collisions. Pediatrics 134, 489–496 (2014).
Nordström, A., Nordström, P. & Ekstrand, J. Sports-related concussion increases the risk of subsequent injury by about 50% in elite male football players. Br. J. Sports Med. 48, 1447–1450 (2014).
Thomas, M. et al. Epidemiology of sudden death in young competitive athletes due to blunt trauma. Pediatrics 128, e1–e8 (2011).
Maron, B. J., Murphy, C. J., Haas, T. S. & Garberich, R. F. Strategies for assessing the prevalence of cardiovascular sudden deaths in young competitive athletes. Int. J. Cardiol. 173, 369–372 (2014).
Corrado, D., Basso, C., Rizzoli, G., Schiavon, M. & Thiene, G. Does sports activity enhance the risk of sudden death in adolescents and young adults? J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 42, 1959–1963 (2003).
Harmon, K. G., Asif, I. M., Klossner, D. & Drezner, J. A. Incidence of sudden cardiac death in National Collegiate Athletic Association athletes. Circulation 123, 1594–1600 (2011).
Maron, B. J. Diversity of views from Europe on national preparticipation screening for competitive athletes. Heart Rhythm 7, 1372–1373 (2010).
Holst, A. G. et al. Incidence and etiology of sports-related sudden cardiac death in Denmark—implications for preparticipation screening. Heart Rhythm 7, 1365–1371 (2010).
Risgaard, B. et al. Sports-related sudden cardiac death in a competitive and a noncompetitive athlete population aged 12 to 49 years: data from an unselected nationwide study in Denmark. Heart Rhythm 11, 1673–1681 (2014).
Winkel, B. G. et al. Nationwide study of sudden cardiac death in persons aged 1–35 years. Eur. Heart J. 32, 983–990 (2011).
Winkel, B. G. et al. Sudden cardiac death in children (1–18 years): symptoms and causes of death in a nationwide setting. Eur. Heart J. 35, 868–875 (2014).
Maron, B. J., Haas, T. S., Doerer, J. J., Thompson, P. D. & Hodges, J. S. Comparison of U.S. and Italian experiences with sudden cardiac deaths in young competitive athletes and implications for preparticipation screening strategies. Am. J. Cardiol. 104, 276–280 (2009).
Mellor, G. et al. Clinical characteristics and circumstances of death in the sudden arrhythmic death syndrome. Circ. Arrhythm. Electrophysiol. 7, 1078–1083 (2014).
Maron, B. J. et al. Recommendations and considerations related to preparticipation screening for cardiovascular abnormalities in competitive athletes: 2007 update: a scientific statement from the American Heart Association Council on Nutrition, Physical Activity, and Metabolism: endorsed by the American College of Cardiology Foundation. Circulation 115, 1643–1655 (2007).
Maron, B. J., Winkel, B. G. & Tfelt-Hansen, J. Perspectives on cardiovascular screening. JAMA 313, 31–32 (2015).
Marijon, E. et al. Sports-related sudden death in the general population. Circulation 124, 672–681 (2011).
Daniels, N. & Sabin, J. E. Setting Limits Fairly. Can We Learn to Share Medical Resources? (Oxford University Press, 2002).
Maron, B. J. & Zipes, D. P. Introduction: eligibility recommendations for competitive athletes with cardiovascular abnormalities—general considerations. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 45, 1318–1321 (2005).
Berdowski, J. et al. Exercise-related out-of-hospital cardiac arrest in the general population: incidence and prognosis. Eur. Heart J. 34, 3616–3623 (2013).
Rutten-Ramos, S., Garberich, R. F., Haas, T. S. & Maron, B. J. Cardiovascular death in student-athletes and in the general population: are trained athletes really at higher risk? [abstract] Circulation 128, A18424 (2013).
Colabianchi, N., Johnston, L. & O'Malley, P. M. Bridging the Gap. Sports Participation in Secondary Schools: Resources Available and Inequalities in Participation [online], (2012).
National College Athletic Association. 1981–82—2012–13 NCAA Sports Sponsorship and Participation Rates Report [online], (2013).
Adabag, A. S., Kuskowski, M. A. & Maron, B. J. Determinants for clinical diagnosis of hypertrophic cardiomyopathy. Am. J. Cardiol. 98, 1507–1511 (2006).
Tasaki, H., Hamasaki, Y. & Ichimaru, T. Mass screening for heart disease of school children in Saga city: 7-year follow up study. Jpn. Circ. J. 51, 1415–1420 (1987).
Haneda, N. et al. Heart diseases discovered by mass screening in the schools of Shimane Prefecture over a period of 5 years. Jpn. Circ. J. 50, 1325–1329 (1986).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
All the authors researched data for the article, contributed to discussion of content, and wrote, reviewed, and edited the manuscript before submission.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
PowerPoint slides
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Maron, B., Friedman, R. & Caplan, A. Ethics of preparticipation cardiovascular screening for athletes. Nat Rev Cardiol 12, 375–378 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1038/nrcardio.2015.21
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nrcardio.2015.21
This article is cited by
-
Athlete Screening for Cardiomyopathies: Recent Insights and Latest Guidelines
Current Cardiovascular Risk Reports (2016)