Summary
Early investigators suggested that endurance training had little influence upon the aerobic function of the prepubescent child. It is shown that the twin explanations of this supposed phenomenon (a high intrinsic level of physical activity and an immaturity of biochemical systems) have little foundation. Moreover, critical examination of the original experiments shows a number of problems of experimental design, often including an inadequate sample size, a lack of control group, an inappropriate pattern of training relative to the initial fitness of the child, and too short a period of observation. Recent, well-designed studies all show a response in prepubescent children. Comparison with adults is hampered by difficulties in matching training intensity, but there is no immediate evidence that the training response of the prepubescent child is less than in an older person. The main basis for the increase of oxygen transport seems an increase of cardiac stroke volume. Plainly, the development of athletic performance and the attack upon cardiac risk factors can be begun before puberty, although in the average prepubescent it may be more important for the school programmes to develop positive, lifelong attitudes, than to maximise aerobic function.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adams FH, Bengtsson E, Berven H, Wegelius C. The physical working capacity of normal schoolchildren. II. Swedish city and country. Pediatrics 28: 243–257, 1961
Alderson J, Crutchley D. Physical education and the national curriculum. In Armstrong N (Ed.) New directions in physical education, Vol. 1, pp.37–62, Human Kinetics, Leeds, 1990
American Academy of Pediatrics. Fitness in the pre-school child. Pediatrics 58: 88–89, 1976
American Academy of Pediatrics. Sports Medicine: health care for young athletes, American Academy of Pediatrics, Chicago, 1983
American College of Sports Medicine. Position statement on the recommended quantity and quality of exercise for developing and maintaining fitness in healthy adults. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 10(3): 7–10 1978
American College of Sports Medicine. The recommended quantity and quality of exercise for developing and maintaining cardiorespiratory and muscular fitness in healthy adults. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 22: 265–274, 1990
Andersen P, Saltin, B. Maximal perfusion of skeletal muscle in man. Journal of Physiology 366: 233–249, 1985
Anderson P, Fröberg K. Maximal oxygen uptake and lactate concentration in highly trained and normal boys during puberty. Acta Physiologica Scandinavica 108: 37A, 1980
Armstrong N, Balding J, Gentle P, Kirby B. Estimation of coronary risk factors in British schoolchildren: a preliminary report. British Journal of Sports Medicine 24: 61–66, 1990
Ashton NG. Relationship of chronic physical activity levels to physiologic and anthropometric variables in 9–10-year old girls. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 15: 143, 1983
Åstrand PO. Experimental studies of physical working capacity in relation to age and sex, Munksgard, Copenhagen 1952
Åstrand PO. Fysiologiska synpunkter pa skolungsdomens fysika fostran: Preliminär rapport till folksam, Central Gymnastic Institute, Stockholm, 1961
Atomi Y, Ohnishi H, Watanabe C, Ishayama M, Kuroda A, et al. Daily physical activity levels in preadolescent boys related to V̇O2max and lactate threshold. European Journal of Applied Physiology 55: 156–161, 1986
Bailey DA. Exercise, fitness and physical education for the growing child. In Orban WAR, (Ed.). Proceedings of National Conference on Fitness and Health, pp. 13–22, Fitness and Amateur Sport, Ottawa, 1974
Bar-Or O. Pediatric sports medicine for the practitioner, Springer Verlag, Berlin 1983
Bar-Or O. Trainability of the pre-pubescent child. Physician and Sportsmedicine 17: 64–82, 1989
Bar-Or O. Disease-specific benefits of training in the child with a chronic disease: What is the evidence? Pediatric Exercise Science 2: 299–312, 1990
Bar-Or O, Shephard RJ, Allen C. Cardiac output of 10–13 year old boys and girls during submaximal exercise. Journal of Applied Physiology 30: 219–223, 1971
Bar-Or O, Zwiren L. Physiological effects of frequency and content of physical education classes and of endurance conditioning on 9- to 10-year old girls and boys. In Bar-Or O (Ed.) Pediatric work physiology IV, pp. 190–208, Wingate Institute, Natanya, Israel, 1973
Benedict G, Vaccaro P, Hatfield BD. Physiological effects of an eight week precision jump program in children. American Corrective Therapy Journal 5: 108–111, 1985
Berenson GS. Cardiovascular risk factors in children: The early natural history of atherosclerosis and essential hypertension, Oxford University Press, New York, 1980
Berg K, Sady SP, Beal D, Savage M, Smith J. Developing an elementary school CHD prevention program. Physician and Sportsmedicine 10: 99–105, 1983
Brown CH, Harrower JR, Deeter MF. The effects of cross-country running on preadolescent girls. Medicine and Science in Sports 4: 1–5, 1972
Bullen BA, Reed RB, Mayer J. Physical activity of obese and non-obese adolescent girls: appraised by motion picture samples. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 14: 211–223, 1964
Canny GJ, Grisdale RK, Marcotte JE, Levison H. Exercise in cystic fibrosis. In Welsh P & Shephard RJ, (Eds) Current therapy in sports medicine, BC Decker, Burlington, Ont. 1985
Chausow SA, Riner WF, Boileau RA. Metabolic and cardiovascular responses of children during prolonged physical activity. Research Quarterly 55: 1–7, 1984
Cumming GR, Friesen W. Bicycle ergometer measurements of maximal oxygen uptake in children. Canadian Journal of Physiology and Pharmacology 45: 937–946, 1967
Cumming GR, Goodwin A, Baggley G, Antel J. Repeated measurements of aerobic capacity during a week of intensive training at a youth’s track camp. Canadian Journal of Physiology and Pharmacology 45: 805–811, 1967
Cumming GR, Goulding D, Baggley G. Failure of school physical education to improve cardiorespiratory fitness. Canadian Medical Association Journal 101: 69–73, 1969
Cunningham DA, van Waterschoot BM, Paterson DH, Lefcoe N, Sangal SP. Reliability and reproducibility of maximal oxygen uptake in children. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 9: 104–108, 1977
Cunningham DA, Paterson DH, Blimkie CJR, Donner AP. Development of cardiorespiratory function in circumpubertal boys; a longitudinal study. Journal of Applied Physiology 56: 301–307, 1984
Daniels J, Oldridge N. Changes on oxygen consumption of young boys during growth and running training. Medicine and Science in Sports 3: 161–165, 1971
Daniels J, Oldridge N, Nagle F, White B. Differences and changes in Vo2 among young runners 10 to 18 years of age. Medicine and Science in Sports 10: 200–203, 1978
Dennison BA, Strauss JH, Mellits ED, Charney E. Childhood physical activity tests: Predictor of adult physical activity levels? Pediatrics 82: 324–330, 1988
Durnin JVGA. Activity patterns in the community. Canadian Medical Association Journal 96: 882–886, 1967
Ekblöm B. Effect of physical training in adolescent boys. Journal of Applied Physiology 27: 350–355, 1969
Eriksson B, Koch B. Cardiac output and intraarterial blood pressure at rest and during submaximal and maximal exercise in 11 to 13 year old boys before and after physical training. In Bar-Or O (Ed.) Pediatric work physiology, pp. 139–150, Wingate Institute, Natanya, Israel, 1973
Eriksson BO, Gollnick PD, Saltin B. Muscle metabolism and enzyme activities after training in boys 11–13 years old. Acta Physiologica Scandinavica 87: 485–497, 1973
Fitness Canada, Canadian youth and physical activity, Fitness and Amateur Sport, Ottawa, 1983
Freedson PS. Field monitoring of physical activity in children. Pediatric Exercise Science 1: 8–18, 1989
Gatch W, Byrd R. Endurance training and cardiovascular function in 9 and 10 year old boys. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation 60: 574–577, 1979
Goode RC, Virgin A, Romet T, Duffin J, Crawford P, et al. Effects of a short period of physical activity in adolescent boys and girls. Canadian Journal of Applied Sport Sciences 1: 241–250, 1976
Gilliam TB, Freedson PS. Effects of a 12 week school fitness program on peak V̇O2, body composition and blood lipids in 7-to 9-year-old children. International Journal of Sports Medicine 1: 73–78, 1980
Gilliam T, Freedson P, Geenen D, Shahaaray B. Physical activity patterns determined by heart rate monitoring in 6 to 7 year old children. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 13: 65–67, 1981
Gilliam TB, MacConnie SE. Coronary heart disease risk in children and their physical activity patterns. In Boileau RA (Ed.) Advances in pediatric sport sciences, Vol. I, Biological issues, pp. 171–188. Human Kinetics, Champaign, Ill., 1984
Godin G, Valois P, Shephard RJ, Desharnais R. Prediction of leisure time exercise behaviour a path analysis (Lisrel V) model. Journal of Behavioural Medicine 10: 145–158, 1987
Goode RC, Virgin A, Romet T, Duffin J, Crawford P, et al. Effects of a short period of physical activity in adolescent boys and girls. Canadian Journal of Applied Sport Sciences 1: 241–250, 1976
Grodjinovsky A, Inbar O, Dotan R, Bar-Or O. Training effect on the anaerobic performance of children as measured by the Wingate anaerobic test. In Berg K & Eriksson BO (Eds) Children and exercise IX, pp. 139–145, University Park Press, Baltimore, 1980
Grodjinovsky A, Bar-Or O. Influence of added physical education hours upon anaerobic capacity, adiposity and grip strength in 12–13 year-old children enrolled in a sports class. In Ilmarinen J & Valimaki I (Eds) Children and sport, pp. 162–169, Springer Verlag, Berlin, 1984
Hamilton P, Andrew GM. Influence of growth and athletic training on heart and lung functions. European Journal of Applied Physiology 36: 27–28, 1976
Ilmarinen J, Rutenfranz J. Longitudinal studies of the changes in habitual physical activity of schoolchildren and working adolescents. In Berg K & Erikson BO (Eds) Children and exercise, pp. 149–159, University Park Press, Baltimore, 1980
Jéquier J-C, LaBarre R, Shephard RJ, Lavallée H, Rajic M, et al. Externe und interne Fehlerquellen einer Längsschnitt-Untersuchungen. In Bauss R & Roth K (Eds) Motorische Entwicklung, Probleme und Ergebnisse von Längschnittuntersuchungen, pp. 383–393, Institüt für Sportwissenschaft, Darmstadt, 1977
Jokl E, McLellan JT. Exercise and cardiac death, University Park Press, Baltimore 1971
Johnson EL. Effects of a 5-day a week versus 2- and 3-day a week physical education class on fitness skill, adipose tissue and growth. Research Quarterly 40: 93–98, 1969
Kanaley JA, Boileau RA. The onset of the anaerobic threshold at three stages of physical maturity. Journal of Sports Medicine 28: 367–374, 1988
Kellet DW, Willan PLT, Bagnall KJ. A study of potential Olympic swimmers: part 2. Changes due to three months of intensive training. British Journal of Sports Medicine 12: 87–92, 1978
Kemper HCG, Vershuur R, Ras KGA, Snel J, Splinter PG, et al. Investigation into the effect of two extra physical education lessons per week during one school year upon the physical development of 12- and 13-year old boys. In Borms J & Hebbelinck M (Eds) Pediatric work physiology pp. 159–166, S Karger AG, Basel 1978
Klesges LM, Klesges RC. The assessment of children’s physical activity: a comparison of methods. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 19: 511–517, 1987
Klesges RC, Haddock CK, Eck LH. A multimethod approach to the measurement of childhood physical activity and its relationship to blood pressure and body weight. Journal of Pediatrics 116: 888–893, 1990
Knuttgen HG, Steendahl K. Fitness of Danish schoolchildren during the course of one academic year. Research Quarterly 34: 34–40, 1963
Kobayashi K, Kitamura K, Miura M, Sodeyama H, Murase Y, et al. Aerobic power as related to body growth and training in Japanese boys: a longitudinal study. Journal of Applied Physiology 44: 666–672, 1978
Kofsky PR, Goode RC, Romet TT. Effects of short period of intense activity on school children. Australian Journal of Sports Medicine 3: 19–21, 1983
Krahenbuhl GS, Skinner JS, Kohrt WM. Developmental aspects of maximal aerobic power in children. Exercise and Sports Sciences Review 13: 503–538, 1985
Larson RL. Physical activity and the growth and development of bone and joint structure. In Rarick GL (Ed.) Physical activity, human growth and development, pp. 32–59, Academic Press, New York, 1973
Lavallée H, Shephard RJ, Jéquier J-C, Rajic M, LaBarre R, et al. Programme d’activités physiques imposé et activités parascolaires libres dans l’étude longitudinale de Trois Rivières. In Lavallée H & Shephard RJ (Eds) Croissance et développement de l’enfant, pp. 61–72, Université de Québec à Trois Rivières, 1982
Lussier L, Buskirk ER. Effect of an endurance training regimen on assessment of work capacity on prepubertal children. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 301: 734–747, 1977
Massicotte DR, MacNab RBJ. Cardiorespiratory adaptations to training at specified intensities in children. Medicine and Science in Sports 6: 242–246, 1974
Mirwald RL, Bailey DA, Cameron N, Rasmussen RL. Longitudinal comparison of aerobic power in active and inactive boys aged 7.0 to 17.0 years. Annals of Human Biology 8: 405–414, 1981
Mirwald RL, Bailey DA. Maximal aerobic power, Sports Dynamics, London, Ont, 1986
Mocellin R, Wasmund U. Investigations on the influence of a running training programme on the cardiovascular and motor performance capacity in 53 boys and girls of a second and third primary school class. In Bar-Or O (Ed.) Pediatric work physiology IV. pp. 279–288, Wingate Institute, Natanya, Israel, 1973
Mukeshi M, Gutin B, Anderson W, Zybert P, Basch C. Validation of the Caltrac movement sensor using direct observation in young children. Pediatric Exercise Science, 2: 249–254, 1990
Murdoch E. Physical education and sport: the interface. In Armstrong N (Ed.) New directions in physical education, Vol. 1, pp. 63–77, Human Kinetics, Leeds, 1990
Noland M, Danner F, Dewalt K, McFadden M, Kotchen JM. The measurement of physical activity in young children. Research Quarterly 61: 146–153, 1990
O’Hara NM, Baranowski T, Simons-Morton BG, Wilson BS, Parcel GS. Validity of the observation of children’s physical activity. Research Quarterly 60: 42–47, 1989
Oseid S, Edwards AM. The asthmatic child in play and sport. Pitman, London, 1983
Pate RR, Blair SN. Exercise and the prevention of atherosclerosis: pediatric implications. In Strong (Ed.) Atherosclerosis: its pediatric aspect, Chap. 13, Grune and Stratton, New York, 1978
Pfeiffer R, Francis RS. Effects of strength training on muscle development in prepubescent, pubescent and postpubescent males. Physician and Sportsmedicine 14(9): 134–143, 1986
Puhl J, Greaves K, Hoyt M, Baranowski T. Childrens activity rating scale (CARS): description and calibration. Research Quarterly 61: 26–36, 1990
Robbins SG. A survey of schools with quality daily physical education. CAHPER Journal 53(6): 10–13, 1987
Rode A, Bar-Or O, Shephard RJ. Cardiac output and oxygen conductance. A comparison of Canadian Eskimo and city dwellers. In Bar-Or O (Ed.) Pediatric work physiology, Wingate Institute, Natanya, Israel, 1973
Rose KD. Relationship of cardiac problems to athletic participation. Journal of the American Medical Association 208: 2319–2324, 1969
Rotstein A, Dotan R, Bar-Or O, Tenenbaum G. Effects of training on anaerobic threshold, maximal aerobic power and anaerobic performance of preadolescent boys. International Journal of Sports Medicine 7: 281–286, 1986
Rowland TW. Aerobic response to endurance training in pre-pubescent children: a critical analysis. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 17: 493–497, 1985
Rowland TW. Oxygen uptake and endurance fitness in children: a developmental perspective. Pediatric Exercise Science 1: 313–328, 1989
Rowland TW. Developmental aspects of physiological function relating to aerobic exercise in children. Sports Medicine 10: 255–266, 1990
Sady SP. Cardiorespiratory exercise training in children. Clinics in Sports Medicine 5: 493–514, 1986
Saltin B. Oxygen transport by the circulatory system during exercise in man. In Keul (Ed.) Limiting factors of physical performance, pp. 235–252, G. Thieme, Stuttgart, 1973
Schmucker B, Hollman W. The aerobic capacity of trained athletes from 6 to 7 years of age. Acta Paediatrica Belgica 28 (Suppl.): 92–104, 1974
Seligar V, Trefny Z, Bartunkova S, Pauer M. The habitual physical activity and physical fitness of 12 year old boys. Acta Paediatrica Belgica 28 (Suppl.): 92–104, 1974
Shasby GB, Hagerman FC. The effects of conditioning on cardiorespiratory function in adolescent boys. Journal of Sport Medicine 97–107, 1975
Shephard RJ. Learning, habituation and training. Internationale Zeitschrift für Angewandte Physiologie 28: 38–48, 1969
Shephard RJ. Intensity, duration and frequency of exercise as determinants of the response to a training regime. Internationale Zeitschrift für Angewandte Physiologie 26: 272–278, 1968
Shephard RJ. Endurance fitness, 2nd ed, University of Toronto Press, Toronto, 1977
Shephard RJ. Exercise for the asthmatic patient: a brief historical review. Journal of Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness 18: 301–307, 1979
Shephard RJ. Physical activity and growth, Year Book Publishers, Chicago, 1982a
Shephard RJ. Physiology and biochemistry of exercise, Praeger Publishing, New York, 1982b
Shephard RJ. Fitness of a nation: lessons from the Canada Fitness Survey, Karger, Basel, 1986
Shephard RJ. Fitness in special populations, Human Kinetics Publishers, Champaign, Ill., 1990a
Shephard RJ. Training programmes and aerobic power of young children. Hermes (Leuven) 21: 387–403, 1990b
Shephard RJ, Allen C, Bar-Or O, Davies CTM, Degré S, et al. The working capacity of Toronto schoolchildren. Canadian Medical Association Journal 100: 560–566, 705-714, 1969
Shephard RJ, Lavallée H, LaRivière G, Rajic M, Brisson GR, et al. La capacité physique des enfants Canadiens: une comparaison entre les enfants Canadiens francais, Canadiens anglais et Esquimaux. I. Consommation maximale d’oxygène et débit cardiaque. Union Médicale du Canada 103: 1767–1777, 1974
Shephard RJ, Lavallée H, Larivière G, Rajic M, Brisson GR, et al. La capacité physique des enfants Canadiens: une comparaison entre les enfants Canadiens-francais, Canadiens-anglais et Esquimaux. III. Psychologie et sociologie des enfants Canadiens-francais. Union Médicale du Canada 104: 1131–1136, 1975
Shephard RJ, Lavallée H, Jéquier J-C, et al. Un programme complémentaire d’éducation physique: étude préliminaire de l’expérience pratiqueée dans le district de Trois Rivières. In LaCour JR (Ed.) Facteurs limitant l’endurance humaine: les techniques d’amélioration de la performance, pp. 43–54, Université de St Etienne, France, 1977
Shephard RJ, Lavallée H, Jéquier J-C, LaBarre R, Rajic M, et al. Seasonal differences in aerobic power. In Shephard RJ & Lavallée H (Eds) Physical fitness assessment: principles, practice and applications, pp. 194–210, CC Thomas, Springield, Ill., 1978a
Shephard RJ, Lavallée H, Rajic M, Jéquier J-C, Brisson GR, et al. Radiographic age in the interpretation of physiological and anthropological data. In Borms J & Hebbelinck M (Eds) Pediatric work physiology, pp. 124–133, Karger AG, Basel, 1978b
Shephard RJ, Jéquier J-C, Lavallée H, LaBarre R, Rajic M, et al. Habitual activity: effects of sex, milieu, season and required activity. Journal of Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness 20: 55–66, 1980a
Shephard RJ, Lavallée H, LaBarre R, Jéquier J-C, Volle M, et al. On the basis of data standardisation in pre-pubescent children, In Ostyn M et al. (Eds) Kinanthropometry 11, Karger AG, Basel, 1980b
Shephard RJ, Lavallée H, Rajic M, Jéquier J-C, Volle M. Body dimensions of Québecois children. Annals of Human Biology 11: 243–252, 1984
Shephard RJ, Ward GR, Lee M. Physical ability of deaf and blind children. In Rutenfranz J, et al. (Eds) Children and exercise XII, pp. 355–362, Human Kinetics, Champaign, Ill., 1987
Sherif CW, Rattray GD. Psychological development and activity in middle-childhood (5–12 years). In Albinson JG & Andrew GM (Eds.) Child in sport and physical activity, pp. 97–132, University Park Press, Baltimore, 1976
Sleap M. Promoting health in primary school physical education. In Armstrong N, (Ed.) New directions in physical education, Vol. 1, pp. 17–36, Human Kinetics, Leeds, 1990
Sprynarova S. Development of the relationship between aerobic capacity and the circulatory and respiratory reaction to moderate activity in boys 11–13 years old. Physiologica Bohemos-lovenica 15: 253–264, 1966
Stewart KJ, Gutin B. Effects of physical training on cardiorespiratory fitness in children. Research Quarterly 47: 110–120, 1976
Sunnegardh J, Bratteby LE. Maximal oxygen uptake, anthropometry and physical activity in a randomly selected sample of 8 and 13 year old children in Sweden. European Journal of Applied Physiology 56: 266–272, 1987
Treiber FA, Musante L, Hartdagan S, Davis H, Levy M, et al. Validation of a heart rate monitor with children in laboratory and field settings. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 21: 338–342, 1989
Trottier A. Results of a national survey on Physical Education in the Provinces. CAHPER Journal 53(6): 8–9, 1987
Tucker LA. The relationship of television viewing to physical fitness and obesity. Adolescence 21: 797–806, 1986
Vaccaro P, Mahon AD. Cardiorespiratory responses to endurance training in children. Sports Medicine 4: 352–363, 1987
Vaccaro P, Clarke DH. Respiratory alterations in 9 to 11 year olds following a season of competitive swimming. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 10: 204–207, 1978
Vaccaro P, Mahon AD. The effect of exercise on coronary heart disease risk factors in children. Sports Medicine 8: 139–153, 1989
Von Döbeln W. Kroppsstorlek, Energiomsätning och Kondition. In Luthman G, et al. (Eds) Handbok i Ergonomi, Almqvist & Wiksell, Stockholm, 1966
Washington RL, Van Gundy JC, Cohen C, Sondheimer H, Wolfe R. Normal aerobic and anaerobic exercise data for North American school-age children. Journal of Pediatrics 112: 223–233, 1988
Weber G, Kartodihardjo W, Klissouras V. Growth and physical training with reference to heredity. Journal of Applied Physiology 40: 211–215, 1976
Weltman A, Janney C, Rians CB, Strand K, Berg B, et al. The effects of hydraulic resistance strength training in pre-pubertal males. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 18: 629–638, 1986
Wilmore JH, McNamara JJ. Prevalence of coronary heart disease risk factors in boys 8 to 12 years of age. Journal of Pediatrics 84: 527–533, 1974
Wright GR, Sidney KH, Shephard RJ. Variance of direct and indirect measurements of aerobic power. Journal of Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness 18: 33–42, 1978
Yoshida TI, Ishiko I, Muraoka I. Effect of endurance training on cardiorespiratory functions of 5-year old children. International Journal of Sports Medicine 1: 91–94, 1980
Zauner CW, Maksud MG, Melichna J. Physiological considerations in training young athletes. Sports Medicine 8: 15–31, 1989
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Shephard, R.J. Effectiveness of Training Programmes for Prepubescent Children. Sports Med 13, 194–213 (1992). https://doi.org/10.2165/00007256-199213030-00004
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2165/00007256-199213030-00004